Food Allergy Support

Discussion Boards => Schools and Food Allergies => Topic started by: CMdeux on March 26, 2012, 02:49:44 PM

FAS has upgraded our forum security. Some members may need to log in again. If you are unable to remember your login information, please email food.allergy.supt@flash.net and we will help you get back in. Thanks for your patience!

Title: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on March 26, 2012, 02:49:44 PM
As far as I know, nobody else has ever done this.  At least nobody has been successful and put it on the net, anyway. 

Precious little exists in the way, even, of figuring out accommodations re: physical disability to start with.

http://www.collegeboard.com/ssd/student/

http://www.ets.org/disabilities-- this has MUCH better guidance (more specifically that addresses physical disability, not just LD's, though I don't know how much it translates to CB... though to be fair, CB is apparently a subsidiary of ETS, so it might.

Quoting myself from another thread...


Me, I'm kind of panicking, realizing everything that I have to do in the next three months so that DD can have accommodations when she takes the PSAT in the fall.  I would just "let it go" but I can't in good conscience do that when it's likely that she'll be in striking distance of a NMS range... a few points one way or the other (like... if she spends part of the test worried about "smelling peanut butter" nearby) could REALLY matter. 

Of course, allergist has more or less quit even evaluating her PA, since it's obviously stable and ugly as sin.  So now we'll have to schedule an appt with HIM ($$) to figure out just what The Collge Board is looking for in terms of "current" evaluation... plus I'll have to chase down the school and probably insist on a 504 meeting THIS SPRING (rather than next fall) so that that is considered "current" as well...

Ai yi yi...

<sigh>  remind me again when this all gets easier??


Thank GOODNESS I finally found a template for doing this with a diabetic child.  Until then, everything that I found related to LD's, which makes most of the advice irrelevant.  It really looks like I'm going to need to put in place:

a) "clock-stopped" and bathroom breaks as needed to manage minor allergic reactions (asthma, hives from contact, etc.)
b) keeping inhaler, epipens, other medication, and cellular communication IN ROOM, with proctor.
c) proctor must be epi-trained.
d) NO food in room, and enough time to do a thorough wipe-down of all 'touch' surfaces prior to testing.
e) access to non-communal bathroom area (avoids food residue on faucet handles, etc.)


That matches up with current 504 accommodations, anyway, so at least that part of things is easy.  Now we just need the 504C and our doc to validate each request.


I'll post inititial documentation and letters to various persons below.  Note:  I'm well aware that few people see any need to go through this process, preferring to simply deal with it by handing a proctor the epipens and hoping for the best.  I've seen that a number of Type I diabetic families have handled things similarly... but not all.  Similarly, while that is probably okay for kids whose FA's don't seem to render them vulnerable to contaminated surfaces, or lead to symptoms that are invisible and incompacitative...  then certainly, I can see why the official route is incomprehensibly labyrinthine.  Not really looking to debate whether or not this is "necessary."  We've already determined that it IS necessary in our particular circumstances.  For others, maybe not. 

  Do know that there is no asterisk after test scores now, even if those are taken with accommmodations in place.

   
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on March 26, 2012, 02:56:56 PM
First steps:

a) review 504/IEP-- this probably needs to be done within the same calendar year as the initial application for accommodations.  (check-- our review meeting is set for April 10)

b) make an appt. with your doc and think through what you'll need from him/her to give to testing agency as "documentation."  Just as with school 504 eval, there is no reason to provide test scores or a waiver for full access.   (Check again-- April 2)

c) talk to school COUNSELOR, who handles the school-side request for accommodations, and who will (should?) help you and the student through the process of applying for accommodations.  If you homeschool (or virtually school, as we do) then you may wish to contact CB/ETS/ACT directly to discuss application with them prior to applying.  (done on March 22 when counselor finally got back to me... this is going to be our weakest link... may call CB myself, actually...  :-/  )

d) allow time-- LOTS of time.  AT LEAST eight weeks prior to the end of the school year for the PSAT, since you pretty much have to have accommodations approved before August, and if you're denied the first time, you need time to turn it around with the help of your school counselor and SpEd staff.  Summer vacation being what it is, plan ahead. 

e) write out your summary of "functional limitations" and specific accommodations-- including justification for each. 





Below, I'll include each of these items (redacted, obviously).

I happened to start with reviewing everything at ETS and CB on the subject, then checked out what TypeI families have had success with, and then worked backwards by doing e) above first. I found that this was helpful in terms of clarifying my thinking on the subject and it has allowed me to have a summary that I could hand off to the school counselor and physician, too.

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on March 26, 2012, 03:17:32 PM
Daily impact of LTFA:
The letter written by (allergist) in 2006 in support of {student}’s eligibility for protections under Section 504 of ADA on the basis of life-threatening food allergy (LTFA) is substantively unchanged at the current time (2012).   (An updated version of that document may be available.)

Risk of anaphylaxis is ever-present, regardless of environment or activities, though the relative level of danger may rise or fall depending upon strict environmental controls of the allergen(s).  A person with LTFA must regard all food, even that consumed by others, as a potential danger to immediate safety.  A person with high sensitivity or documented reactivity to contact alone, such as this student, must regard all surfaces touched by others as potentially contaminated outside of his/her own home (if allergen-free), and will often be particularly distressed by smelling the allergen (it is not unusual for those with immediate hypersensitivity to food allergens to have accurate but extremely heightened awareness of the scent of an allergen).  This type of anxiety is extreme, though not irrational, given that the affected person is aware of proximity to a substance that they are fully aware can kill them in microscopic quantities.
  This student has experienced severe anaphylaxis from occult/casual exposures on multiple occasions, and in most instances a cause could never be identified. An additional concern is that this student has presented with atypical anaphylaxis (CNS and cardiac features, without airway or skin symptoms), which is extremely difficult for even highly skilled observers to identify in a timely fashion.  Such anaphylaxis may initially be erroneously dismissed as anxiety, even by the person experiencing it.  Such a mistake can be deadly, because any delay in proper treatment increases the chance of a fatal outcome.
  During singular, important events such as testing via the College Board’s examinations, it is prudent to avoid any risk which can realistically be mitigated or minimized.  This allows the student the same opportunity for success as that afforded to her unaffected peers, and reduces the chance for disruption for other participants.

 
Necessary accommodations:

1)   The environment must be made as free from food and food residue (traces, smells, etc.) as is possible.  The student must have time before the examination begins to decontaminate the surfaces that s/he is likely to touch during the course of testing, and no other persons should subsequently have the opportunity to touch those surfaces during the examination period.  Surfaces may be contaminated unknowingly by anyone who has food residue (even invisible traces) on his/her hands and subsequently touches other surfaces or objects.  This student has demonstrated that she has a very tiny threshold dose necessary to cause a severe reaction—it is certainly a quantity too small to be seen with the naked eye.  This student’s history strongly suggests that this type of exposure poses a real risk in any crowded or uncontrolled environment in which others are, or have been, eating an allergen or a food which contains one.  Risk of provoking anaphylaxis—or the anxiety that it might be provoked--must be minimized as much as is feasible, given the high-stakes nature of testing and the difficulty/impossibility of rescheduling.  Crushing anxiety as a result of being trapped in a space which is obviously (to the allergic person) heavily contaminated would impose an undue burden on the student and could also substantially impair his/her performance.  In addition, such a high-stakes situation often provides an incentive to the student to ignore symptoms, hope to “tough it out” and delay proper treatment.

2)   Given that it is impossible to make the risk of anaphylaxis negligible, a responsible adult who has some knowledge how to recognize and respond to anaphylaxis must be present with the student during the examination; during anaphylaxis, impairment can be so profound that the student may not even be able to initiate treatment.  Delays in treatment, even just minutes, may result in death or permanent injury.

3)   Emergency medications (epinephrine, oral antihistamines, topical antihistamines, rescue inhaler, etc.) must remain accessible to the student.  A means of contacting emergency responders (and parents) must also be available in the exam room.  Delays in proper treatment, even just a few minutes, may result in death or permanent injury.

4)   “Clock-stopped” breaks as needed for management/evaluation of symptoms.  In the event of minor symptoms, the student must be allowed a break in order to assess risk and to undertake appropriate intervention with the clock stopped on the examination.  Such intervention may require washing effected skin, changing contaminated clothing, consulting with a parent regarding medication, using an inhaler, or seeking fresh air.  Under no circumstances should the student be allowed to do any of those things without another person being aware of the reason for the break, the student’s location, and his/her status at all times.  Allergic reactions can quickly escalate, becoming life-threatening without warning.  If the student requires oral antihistamines to treat a minor reaction, s/he will consider the fact that the cognitive impairment that these medications induce (which generally lasts 4-8 hours) may invalidate the results of testing.

5)   The proctor must be prepared to recognize and respond to anaphylaxis by using an epinephrine autoinjector and then immediately calling 911 from the test site.  The student and her parents will provide education to the proctor to aid him/her in recognizing the warning signs of anaphylaxis and the correct use of an epinephrine autoinjector.  In the event of anaphylaxis, the student must be treated with epinephrine in situ and immediately transported to the nearest emergency room via EMS; delays in treatment may result in death or permanent injury, and persons experiencing severe anaphylaxis may rapidly become incapacitated and unable to initiate treatment. It is also extremely important that a person experiencing anaphylaxis not be moved to an upright position or allowed to walk or stand, as this can result in immediate cardiac arrest.   In the event of anaphylaxis, the student will clearly be unable to complete the examination; his/her scores should be invalidated and, if possible, s/he should be reseated to take the exam at a later date.




That's what DH and I came up with as a succinct but crystal clear set of explanations and justifications.  We already know that this is going to result in individual testing-- just as with Type I students, that's actually the most appropriate thing for a student that may have to evaluate a medical condition during the exam.  I provided this document to (initialy somewhat clueless) school counselor, who now understands the nature of the restrictions imposed by LTFA-- and the specific need for each accommodation.  I have hope that this means that he'll be able to help us; at least now he's willing (whereas before he was somewhat skeptical, frankly).



Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on March 26, 2012, 03:30:59 PM
Our physician (remember, he's the totally AWESOME allergist that had no problem simply printing out the FAS gold-standard '504-qualifier' and signing it) is getting the following cover letter:



{Dr. Awesome},

We have an appointment for {date}, but it may be helpful for you to have some information about the purpose of our visit beforehand.  We need updated documentation for {student}’s 504 eligiblity/plan, and also for the College Board, as {student} begins standardized testing in high school.  I expect that the former will require little more than updating the letter that you provided in {year} (included).  I do not know of any instances in which the College Board has granted special testing accommodations specifically for a life-threatening food allergy; {student} may well prove to be the first such case. 

We will need particular documentation of the nature and extent of {Student}’s qualifying disability for the College Board.  This is necessary to secure an appropriate testing environment during the PSAT, SAT, and AP exams.  {Student} will take the PSAT/NMSQT next October, providing that accommodations can be worked out prior to the registration dates (starting in August). Their requirements are beyond the ADA and ADAA standard to demonstrate functional limitation, and the process is lengthy; as much as eight weeks for an initial determination (which may be denied and need to be resubmitted with different verbiage or documentation).  This process is less than clear when it comes to accommodating chronic medical conditions and there is little guidance as to proper documentation and verbiage.  Most of the official guidance simply doesn’t apply to chronic physical conditions at all. I’ve included the information provided by the College Board, though I found it frustratingly vague.  Lacking a template/example, I’ve been adapting the strategies used by families with Type I diabetes since many of the accommodations are of a similar nature.  I’ve also included documentation that seems to have been successful for those students, because the verbiage that the College Board is apparently seeking is not obvious, by any means.
 
Finally, I’ve included a summary of {student}’s particular “functional limitations” (the parlance of the College Board) and the justifications for particular testing accommodations that are natural extensions of those limitations.   We will need something like this from you if we are to obtain appropriate testing accommodations for {student}.  It must be quite plainly-worded and specific with respect to accommodations, since her 504 plan alone doesn’t include a lot of guidance on the subject (the school never assumes duty-of-care, so it isn’t necessary as long as they do individual testing, which is how her 504 plan is written).   We will have the assistance of {student}'s school counselor, though this counselor is new to the position, does not fully understand the nature and impact of food allergy, and given the nature of virtual schooling will not be “on-site” for the testing location. 

I can provide you with electronic copies of any of the materials that I’ve included, either via e-mail or on a USB drive.

Thank you, as always,


{Us}
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: DrummersMom on March 28, 2012, 06:15:25 AM
Thanks for sharing your experience. I am beginning this process for my DD who has a 504 for anxiety, not food allergies. She won't take PSAT for two years but her school suggested we start the process now. Hopefully, they will be as helpful when we begin the process for DS with FAs in five years.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on March 28, 2012, 04:31:32 PM
There is some good news, at least unofficially!

When the school counselor spoke with someone at the College Board, they agreed that (based on our no-holds-barred outlay of daily impact and justifications for accommodation) that this all seemed quite straightforward and reasonable.

Keeping my fingers crossed that it still seems that way after next week, but that is at least some good news.

 :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 02, 2012, 01:13:48 PM
Okay, this is one of the documents from the diabetes parent-forum linked above:



Update:

It is necessary for your specialist physician to sign a letter specifically stating much of the following--



Re: [Child’s name],

Please find below information to support the Student Eligibility Form for Accommodation on College Board Tests based on Medical Disability for {Diagnosis/condition}.


1. State the specific disability, as diagnosed:
Specific, but succinct detailed description of disability.  E.g.-- Type I diabetes mellitus; requirement for disease management including blood glucose (sugar) testing and management of insulin pump and insertion site.

2. Current status:
E.g.--
[Child’s name] has Type I diabetes, which is a chronic disease without remission.  Type I diabetes requires testing of blood sugars and administration of injected insulin multiple times a day, both scheduled and on an as needed basis. The patient was last seen in the [Name clinic or doctor ] on [date]. At that time her blood sugars and hemoglobin A1c were consistent with the diagnosis of diabetes.  She attends the clinic 4 times a year for follow up and medical management.

3. Provide relevant educational, developmental, and medical history
{brief, just a few sentences, but needs to address the range of impact from a medical standpoint}  E.g.--The patient was diagnosed with type I diabetes in [date of diagnosis], at which time she presented to the hospital with a blood glucose over 500. The patient is currently managed with insulin administered via insulin pump.  She has had a school medical treatment plan in place since that time, and currently has a 504 plan to educational performance due to her medical condition, as well (see attached).

4. Describe the comprehensive testing and techniques used to arrive at the diagnosis:
{diagnostic criteria, the significance of test results or history}

5. Describe the functional limitations

{Must explain in what manner and to what degree the student is "impaired" relative to peers and in the context of daily life/management of the condition.}  E.g.--
The student’s medical condition requires that she is able to manage her diabetes by frequently testing her blood sugar, and modifying her insulin dose and food intake. In some cases she may need to change her infusion site.  Immediate response is essential to stabilize functional performance and ensure both short and long term health. These are all medically required activities that take away from test taking time and must be addressed immediately. Additionally, careful management of blood glucose is essential because hypo- and hyperglycemia are associated with decreased cognition (see references below).


6. Describe the specific accommodations requested

Justification may be needed for each if the accommodations are "uncommon" in some way (most physically disabling conditions will be in this category).  E.g.--
The student is NOT requesting extended time, but rather to have frequent and/or extended breaks, if needed, as dictated by her medical condition and specific blood glucose measurements at the time of testing.  In some cases it can take 20 minutes or more for adjustments to take effect.  {For less common or well-understood, or more highly variable conditions, additional justification/explanation may be prudent}.

7. Establish the professional credentials of the evaluator:
(M.D., sub-specialty, etc.)


Sincerely,

Health Care Provider’s Name and contact info


(the original document included references, but recall that much, MUCH more official "psych" studies have been conducted re: diabetes than with LTFA.)

Allergist loved the formatting on this document, though he agreed with all of our summary statements and justifications above, as well.  I just need to merge the two documents at this point and let him have them back in order to print them on letterhead.  I'll probably be fishing for reference information as I work on this.   

 :thumbsup:

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: twinturbo on April 02, 2012, 05:43:33 PM
I'd wish her luck but I know she's gonna rock that test.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 02, 2012, 06:30:29 PM
 :thumbsup:  I think so, too.  (Which is why I'm going to all this trouble, basically... if I didn't think that she were likely to score in the top 1-5%, a few points wouldn't matter so much one way or the other, YK?)



Right now, I am pulling everything into the format that the doc liked, but I need to add some references in there.  I know that they are out there, I just need to FIND them again...

(my apologies, this is a lengthy list; I'll eventually split these out into component posts associated with each reference point)


References:

1.   Future anaphylaxis likely in spite of avoidance.

This, but it also plays to several OTHER points.  Terrific article, really:

Nguyen-Luu NU, Ben-Shoshan M, et al. Inadvertent exposures in children with peanut allergy. Pediatr Allergy Immunol. 2012 Mar;23(2):134-140.

Quote
Abstract
To cite this article: Nguyen-Luu NU, Ben-Shoshan M, Alizadehfar R, Joseph L, Harada L, Allen M, St-Pierre Y, Clarke A. Inadvertent exposures in children with peanut allergy. Pediatr Allergy Immunol 2011: Doi: 10.1111/j.1399-3038.2011.01235.x ABSTRACT: Objectives:  To determine the annual incidence, characterize the severity and management, and identify predictors of accidental exposure among a cohort of children with peanut allergy. Methods:  From 2004 to November 2009, parents of Canadian children with a physician-confirmed peanut allergy completed entry and follow-up questionnaires about accidental exposures over the preceding year. Logistic regression analyses were used to examine potential predictors. Results:  A total of 1411 children [61.3% boys, mean age 7.1 yr (SD, 3.9)] participated. When all children were included, regardless of length of observation, 266 accidental exposures occurred over 2227 patient-years, yielding an annual incidence rate of 11.9% (95% CI, 10.6-13.5). When all accidental exposures occurring after study entry and patients providing <1 yr of observation were excluded, 147 exposures occurred over a period of 1175 patient-years, yielding a rate of 12.5% (95% CI, 10.7-14.5). Only 21% of moderate and severe reactions were treated with epinephrine. Age ≥13 yr at study entry (OR, 2.33; 95% CI, 1.20-4.53) and a severe previous reaction to peanut (OR, 2.04; 95% CI, 1.44-2.91) were associated with an increased risk of accidental exposure, and increasing disease duration (OR, 0.88; 95% CI, 0.83-0.92) with a decreased risk. Conclusion:  The annual incidence rate of accidental exposure for children with peanut allergy is 12.5%. Children with a recent diagnosis and adolescents are at higher risk. Hence, education of allergic children and their families is crucial immediately after diagnosis and during adolescence. As many reactions were treated inappropriately, healthcare professionals require better education on anaphylaxis management.
  (emphasis mine)  Ding-ding-ding.  This one is a MAJOR winner.   :yes:

2.   Anaphylaxis outcomes are unpredictable.

I think that is this one, but I'll check it later:
Sampson HA, Mendelson L, Rosen JP. Fatal and near-fatal anaphylactic reactions to food in children and adolescents. N Engl J Med. 1992;327(6):380-384.
Could be this one instead:
Yunginger JW, Sweeney KG, Sturner WQ, et al. Fatal food-induced anaphylaxis. JAMA. 1988;260(10):1450-1452.

This is the one that pretty much says, Look, you can do everything right, but still have a fatality sometimes.  (This is the scariest freaking article EVER, IMO.)  :hiding:

Pumphrey RS. Lessons for management of anaphylaxis from a study of fatal reactions. Clin Exp Allergy.2000;30 :1144– 1150

3.   Highest risks for fatality—adolescent, female, previous severe Hx, nut allergy, asthma):

The first of these is the best of them:
Shah E, Pongracic J. Food-induced anaphylaxis: who, what, why, and where? Pediatr Ann. 2008 Aug;37(8):536-41.
Quote
Abstract
Food-induced anaphylaxis is a leading cause of anaphylaxis treated in emergency departments and hospitals around the world. Peanuts, tree nuts, fish, and shellfish are the most commonly implicated foods. Food-induced anaphylaxis may occur in any age group and with any food. However, food-induced anaphylaxis fatalities disproportionately affect adolescents and young adults with peanut and tree nut allergy. Individuals who have both IgE-mediated food allergy and asthma are at a higher risk for food-induced anaphylaxis fatality. Delayed administration of epinephrine is also associated with fatal outcome. Often, in fatal reactions, the food allergen is unknowingly ingested away from home, in settings such as restaurants and schools. Although avoidance of food allergens is critical, timely administration of epinephrine is also of great importance in the treatment of food-induced anaphylaxis. Patients, families, and caregivers must be well educated regarding the signs, symptoms and risk factors for anaphylaxis. They must also be counseled on the importance of strict food avoidance of the implicated food allergens, compliance with having self-injectable epinephrine available at all times, and the importance of timely administration of epinephrine, even when cutaneous symptoms are lacking


Muñoz-Furlong A, Weiss CC. Characteristics of food-allergic patients placing them at risk for a fatal anaphylactic episode. Curr Allergy Asthma Rep. 2009;9(1):57-63.

Bock SA, Muñoz-Furlong A, Sampson HA. Fatalities due to anaphylactic reactions to foods. J Allergy Clin Immunol.2001;107 :191– 193


4.   Sampson Pediatrics—Food anaphylaxis, grading chart.(This, by the way, is the source of our community's "plain English" grading chart!)
Sampson HA. Anaphylaxis and emergency treatment. Pediatrics.2003;111 :1601– 1608

5.   Position paper/treatment guidance for diagnosis of food allergy?:

Either of:
Lieberman P, Nicklas RA, Oppenheimer J, et al. The diagnosis and management of anaphylaxis practice parameter: 2010 update. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2010;126(3):477-480 e1-42.

or
Boyce JA, Assa’ad A, Burks AW, et al. Guidelines for the diagnosis and management of food allergy in the United States: summary of the NIAID-Sponsored Expert Panel report. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2010;126(6):1105-1118.

6.   DBPC challenge poses unnecessary risk in patients with severe and clear rxn hx.
(well, I think that Pumphrey article from above pretty nicely sums up why THIS is a really crappy way to diagnose a PA in someone who has already anaphylaxed, don't you?  :tongue:)
Coupled with that one:
van der Zee T, Dubois A, et al. The eliciting dose of peanut in double-blind, placebo-controlled food challenges decreases with increasing age and specific IgE level in children and young adults. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2011 Nov;128(5):1031-6. Epub 2011 Aug 31.

Mankad VS, Williams LW, et al. Safety of open food challenges in the office setting. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol. 2008 May;100(5):469-74.

7.   Identifying shock vs. anxiety, docs mistake anaphylaxis in emergency rooms

THIS.
Quote
Pathophysiology
Anaphylactic mediators cause vasodilation, fluid extravasation, smooth muscle contraction and increased mucosal secretions. Death may occur from hypoxaemia (due to upper airway angioedema, bronchospasm and mucus plugging) and/or shock (due to massive vasodilation, fluid shift into the extravascular space and depressed myocardial function).17 While compensatory tachycardia in response to hypotension is considered a characteristic feature, sudden bradycardia with cardiovascular collapse and cardiac arrest may occur before any skin features become apparent.18 The cause of this phenomenon is unclear, but it is an important clinical feature to recognise in order to avoid making an initial misdiagnosis of a “panic attack” or “vasovagal reaction” in cases where dyspnoea, nausea, anxiety, and bradycardia may occur just before cardiovascular collapse.




Brown SGA, Mullins RJ, Gold MS. Anaphylaxis: diagnosis and management. Med J Aust 2006; 185 (5): 283-289. 


Not exactly, but related to this notion of rapid cardiovascular incompetence leading to death outside of hospital settings, esp. when laypersons are required to 'evaluate' and decide whether or not such a reaction is or is not anaphylaxis:

Simons FE. Anaphylaxis, killer allergy: long-term management in the community. J Allergy Clin Immunol.2006;117 :367– 377


8.   Anxiety impairs performance?

Staal, M. Stress, Cognition, and Human Performance: A Literature Review and Conceptual Framework, NASA Ames Research Center, 2004. retrieved from www.human-factors.arc.nasa.gov April 2, 2012.


Duncko, R., Johnson, L., Merikangas, K., & Grillon, C. (2009). Working memory performance after acute exposure to the cold pressor stress in healthy volunteers. Neurobiology of Learning and Memory, 91, 377–381.

Lee, J. H. (1999). Test anxiety and working memory. Journal of Experimental Education, 67, 218-225.

Park, C. R., Zoladz, P. R., Conrad, C. D., Fleshner, M., & Diamond, D.M. (2008). Acute predator stress impairs the consolidation and retrieval of hippocampus-dependent memory in male and female rats. Learning and Memory, 15, 271-280.

Baddeley, A., Eysenck, M. W. & Anderson, M. C. (2010). Memory. Psychology Press: New York.

Jelicic, M., Geraerts, E., Merckelbach, H., Guerrieri, R. (2004). Acute Stress Enhances Memory For Emotional Words, But Impairs Memory For Neutral Words. International Journal of Neuroscience, 114, 1343- 1351.
9.   Ignoring symptoms in adolescents?  “Toughing it out” syndrome & anxiety-- psychological factors, basically--

Not specifically about this particular thing, but more about "risk taking" and "peer pressure" which of course is related--

Anaphylaxis in Schools & Other Settings, 2nd Edition Revised, Canadian Society of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. 2005.

Similarly (and I'm following the citations trail from this one here):

Marklund B, Wilde-Larsson B, et al. Adolescents' experiences of being food-hypersensitive: a qualitative study. BMC Nursing 2007, 6:8
(That one is a real treasure trove, by the way.)

Steinberg L. Risk Taking in Adolescence. What Changes, and
Why? Ann N Y Acad Sci 2004, 1021:51-58.

Steinberg L: Cognitive and affective development in adolescence.
TRENDS in Cognitive Sciences 2005, 9(2):69-74.

10.   Early treatment = better outcomes.  Delays = deaths.
Simons KJ, Simons FE. Epinephrine and its use in anaphylaxis: current issues. Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol. 2010;10(4):354-361.

11.   Dey—how to use an autoinjector

12.   Standing up during shock = cardiac arrest.
Pumphrey RS. Fatal posture in anaphylactic shock. J Allergy Clin Immunol.2003;112 :451– 452

Brown SG. Cardiovascular aspects of anaphylaxis: implications for treatment and diagnosis. Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol. 2005; 5(4):359-64.




I'll have to come back to this later and fill in the references in the list.  The only ones that I know I'm going to be digging for are 6 and 9, but I've seen them published before, so I'm pretty sure that the info is out there.



And on a related note... this is the reference that I wanted to pull out of my purse for DD's surgeon the other day...

Dewachter P, Jouan-Hureaux V, Franck P, et al. Anaphylactic shock: a form of distributive shock without inhibition of oxygen consumption. Anesthesiology 2005; 103:40. 

and this one--

Pumphrey RS, Roberts IS. Postmortem findings after fatal anaphylactic reactions. J Clin Pathol 2000; 53:273.

Most notably--
Quote
CONCLUSIONS: In many cases of fatal anaphylaxis no specific macroscopic findings are present at postmortem examination. This reflects the rapidity and mode of death, which is often the result of shock rather than asphyxia.


Yes, that's right.  Fully competent airways and cardiovascular collapse.  NOT mutually exclusive things.  Who knew??   ;)




Finally, even MILD symptoms (treated or untreated) negatively impact performance:

Walker S, Khan-Wasti S, et al. Seasonal Allergic rhinitis is associated with a detrimental effect on examination performance in United Kingdom teenagers: Case control study. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2007 Aug;120(2):381-7. Epub 2007 Jun 8.

The reason why that one is ultimately important is that most "inhalation" reactive patients aren't considered (at least officially) to be at "real risk" of anaphylaxis from such exposure, which is generaly regarded as "annoying" and not particularly 'dangerous' in nature.  This may be true, but in an exam setting, "annoying" is enough to impair performance significantly. 


I'm still hunting references re: fear and impairment at cognitively demanding tasks.  It's there, but it's also indirect.  The military and NASA have both studied it, for obvious reasons.  Anxiety isn't the same phenomenon as "fear" in physiological terms.  Smelling a potent allergen during a high-stakes, stressful situation is regarded by the amygdala as "important!  Drop everything NOW-NOW-NOW" and is pretty much physiologicaly impossible to "tune out" in order to focus attention on the cognitive tasks requiring working memory.  Having a lot of trouble finding applicable resources for that one, though.  Mostly because it's a highly challenging thing to study, which is the same problem that NASA and the Air Force have had with it.  It's unethical to make someone fear for their life while you are demanding their "best" otherwise.   ~)

 

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Mfamom on April 03, 2012, 10:30:51 AM
Good Job!!  Wow, very thorough, well thought out.  You put a lot of time in this and I appreciate you sharing with us. 
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 03, 2012, 02:58:15 PM
Okay-- more about processing and 'acute stress' (or basically, threat-perception);

van Marle HJ, Hermans EJ, et al. From specificity to sensitivity: how acute stress affects amygdala processing of biologically salient stimuli. Biol Psychiatry. 2009 Oct 1;66(7):649-55. Epub 2009 Jul 12.


Interesting.  Basically, this says that your brain tends to become pretty damned FIXATED on threats, and become 'primed' to see everything that way, fixating on evaluation of danger/risk to the exclusion of other activities...  (Duh.  Who knew??)

Quote
RESULTS: A variety of physiological and psychological measures confirmed successful induction of moderate levels of acute stress. More importantly, this context manipulation shifted the amygdala toward higher sensitivity as well as lower specificity, that is, stress induction augmented amygdala responses to equally high levels for threat-related and positively valenced stimuli, thereby diminishing a threat-selective response pattern. Additionally, stress amplified sensory processing in early visual regions and the face responsive area of the fusiform gyrus but not in a frontal region involved in task execution.

CONCLUSIONS: A shift of amygdala function toward heightened sensitivity with lower levels of specificity suggests a state of indiscriminate hypervigilance under stress. Although this represents initial survival value in adverse situations where the risk for false negatives in the detection of potential threats should be minimized, it might similarly play a causative role in the sequelae of traumatic events

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 03, 2012, 03:49:56 PM
More on olfactory threat-perception in particular:

Elizabeth A. Krusemark, Wen Li. Enhanced Olfactory Sensory Perception of Threat in Anxiety: An Event-Related fMRI Study. Chemosensory Perception, 2012; 5

It is really important to know that this is a direct line to the meso-limbic brain in understanding the (probably) profound cognitive impairment induced by 'smelling' an anaphylaxis trigger.  There is almost no way for the cortical regions of the brain to 'over-ride' this kind of input in order to function completely normally.  It'd be like ignoring someone screaming profanities and waving a gun within a few feet of you.    Seriously.

In animal studies, this kind of input (predator scent, basically) has really profound impact on behavior.    Olfaction also has a significant ability (beyond other sensory inputs, according to some researchers) in triggering PTSD episodes.  Obviously the PTSD association probably isn't valid for someone who hasn't experienced severe anaphylaxis, but it very well could be for someone who has.


(I've been kind of digging getting to know the research in this area after spending over a decade away from the field of neuroscience research.  Really interesting stuff-- once subjects associate olfactory inputs with threat, their powers of discrimination and detection become pretty super-human-- and very accurate, even to the point of differentiating sterioisomers which are classed as "non-differentiable" believe it or not.  It's fascinating.  I think that it goes a long way to explaining "that smell" that some allergic people experience with their food allergens.   :yes:   I might pass that along to our allergist just for fun, even though it doesn't really have a place in the official packet for the College Board or our 504 team. )




 
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 03, 2012, 08:21:12 PM
Taking a deep breath...


This is the finished document.



Re: {Student name},

Please find below information to support the Student Eligibility Form for Accommodation on College Board Tests based on Medical Disability (Life-Threatening Food Allergy/Anaphylaxis).

1. State the specific disability, as diagnosed.

{student} has food-induced life-threatening anaphylaxis to {allergens}.  Management requires avoidance of all ingestion, inhalation, or contact with allergens.  This task requires continuous risk management in surroundings, avoidance of known/observed risks, and evaluation of possible symptoms of emergent anaphylaxis.  Most critically, proper management requires the understanding that future anaphylaxis is likely in spite of avoidance (1).  Patients and their families must always be prepared to rapidly treat anaphylaxis with life-saving medications and to seek professional emergent medical care.  Anaphylaxis may result in death or permanent injury within minutes; appropriate response reduces the likelihood of poor outcomes, but anaphylaxis may be fatal in spite of optimal care (2, 3).

2. Current status

{student}'s history and test results (RAST, skin-prick testing) indicate that her allergies must be regarded as life-long and life-threatening.  Management requires aggressive measures to reduce her risks of exposure, such as: a) avoiding areas where allergen consumption is ubiquitous, b) frequently washing her hands and surfaces, or requesting that others do so, c) carrying safe food and drink as needed/anticipated, and/or d) leaving environments which she has reason to regard as unsafe.  She always carries emergency medications (epinephrine autoinjectors, bronchodilators) to treat anaphylaxis and a means (cellular phone) to call for emergency medical assistance and transportation to the nearest hospital.  She takes daily antihistamines to minimize allergic sensitivity, but this does not mitigate anaphylaxis risk.  {student} is seen by a board certified allergist at least biannually for management advice, testing as needed, and evaluation. She was last seen by {Dr. Awesome} on {date}. 

3. Provide relevant educational, developmental, and medical history

{student} has required emergency medical care for anaphylaxis on multiple occasions.  She has a history of rapidly progressing anaphylaxis involving the gastrointestinal, skin, respiratory and cardiovascular systems.  Due to this reaction history and her age she is at elevated risk of fatal anaphylaxis (3, 4).  {statement of educational history}  {Student} has had an active 504 plan which addresses {specific areas} since {date}.  That plan is current and will be (was) reviewed on {Date} (see attached).

4. Describe the comprehensive testing and techniques used to arrive at the diagnosis:

{Student} was diagnosed with life-threatening food allergies at the age of 11 months, following emergency medical care for peanut-induced anaphylaxis.  Since that time, she has also been diagnosed with life-threatening allergies to tree nuts (almonds, cashews, pistachios, etc) and eggs.  She has experienced several life-threatening allergic reactions.  {Student} has a clinical history of reactivity to ingestion of microscopic quantities of allergens, contact with allergens, and inhalation of allergens.  {Student's} history includes reactions which feature many of the clinical observations known to be associated with food anaphylaxis (5).  Current best practices (6) indicate that clear patient history of severe reaction, confirmed by skin prick testing or allergen-specific RAST to evaluate blood IgE levels, is an adequate means of diagnosing a life-threatening food allergy.  {Student} has a history ranging from localized reactions through life-threatening anaphylactic responses to multiple routes of exposure (ingestion, contact, and inhalation).   With {student}'s reaction history, she is not a candidate for a food challenge (6-8).   Skin prick testing and/or IgE values have confirmed the diagnosis suggested by her clinical history with peanut, tree nuts, and egg.  Accidental exposures and reactions have occurred with unfortunate regularity in spite of good compliance with avoidance measures, indicating that there is little reason for annual diagnostic testing for peanut or tree nuts at this time.

5. Describe the functional limitations

Risk of anaphylaxis is ever-present, regardless of environment or activities, though the relative level of danger may rise or fall depending upon strict environmental controls of the allergen(s) and the individual’s physiological state, which can vary unpredictably.  A person with life-threatening food allergies must regard all food, even that consumed by others, as a potential risk to immediate safety.  A person with high sensitivity or documented reactivity to contact alone, such as this student, must additionally regard all surfaces touched by others as potentially contaminated outside of his/her own home (if allergen-free).  Such individuals will often be distressed by smelling an allergen (it is not unusual for those with immediate hypersensitivity to food allergens to have accurate but extremely heightened awareness of the scent of an allergen).  This type of anxiety is not irrational, given that the affected person senses proximity to a substance that they are fully aware (both viscerally and rationally) can kill them in microscopic quantities within minutes, and that the individual must consider that this allergen is likely to be lurking on surfaces nearby if it can be smelled.

This student has experienced severe anaphylaxis from occult/casual exposures on multiple occasions, and in most instances a cause could never be identified.  Once systemic allergic symptoms begin, no matter how mild, it is impossible to know how the reaction will progress, particularly when no cause is obvious.  For this reason, all allergy symptoms must be treated as possible precursors to life-threatening anaphylaxis.  An additional concern is that this student has presented with atypical anaphylaxis (CNS and cardiac features, without airway or skin symptoms), which is extremely difficult for even highly skilled observers to identify in a timely fashion (3, 8).  Such anaphylaxis may initially be erroneously dismissed as anxiety, even by the person experiencing it; this is clearly much more probable in a situation which is plausibly anxiety-provoking and in any situation where pausing to evaluate symptoms has a high cost.  If the symptoms are not test anxiety, but anaphylaxis-induced shock, such an error might easily be fatal.
  During singular, important events such as testing via the College Board’s examinations, it is prudent to avoid any risk which can realistically be mitigated or minimized in order to reduce the opportunity for such confusion.  This allows the student the same opportunity for success as that afforded to her unaffected peers, and reduces the chance for disruption for other participants. 


6. Describe the specific accommodations requested

Necessary accommodations:

1)   The environment must be as free from food and food residue (traces, smells, etc.) as is practical.  The student must have time before the examination begins to decontaminate the surfaces that s/he is likely to touch during the course of testing, and no other persons should subsequently have the opportunity to touch those surfaces during the examination period.  Surfaces may be contaminated unknowingly by any person who has food residue (even invisible traces) on his/her hands and subsequently touches other surfaces or objects.  This student has demonstrated that she has a very low threshold dose necessary to elicit a severe reaction—quantities too small to be seen with the naked eye.  This student’s history strongly suggests that this type of exposure poses a real risk in any crowded or uncontrolled environment in which others are, or have been, eating an allergen or a food which contains one.  Areas used for food preparation or consumption are not suitable.   Risk of provoking anaphylaxis—or the anxiety that it might be provoked--must be minimized as much as is feasible, given the high-stakes nature of testing and the difficulty/impossibility of rescheduling.  Crushing anxiety as a result of being trapped in a space which is obviously (to the allergic person) heavily contaminated would impose an undue burden on the student and could also substantially impair his/her performance (9, 10).  In addition, such a high-stakes situation often provides an incentive to the student to ignore symptoms, hope to “tough it out” and delay proper treatment.   Adolescents in particular do not weigh risks ideally at the best of times, and less so when under stress (11-13).  It is worth noting that {student} is not yet thirteen years of age, and her relative immaturity may enhance those already significant issues.


2)   Emergency medications (epinephrine, oral antihistamines, topical antihistamines, rescue inhaler, etc.) must remain accessible to the student.  A means of contacting emergency responders (and parents) must also be available in the exam room.  Delaying treatment, even just a few minutes, may result in death or permanent injury (2-5, 8, 14, 15).

3)   “Clock-stopped” breaks as needed for management of symptoms.  In the event of minor symptoms, the student must be allowed a break in order to assess risk and to undertake appropriate intervention with the clock stopped on the examination.  Such intervention may require washing effected skin, changing contaminated clothing, consulting with a parent regarding medication, using an inhaler, or seeking fresh air. The proctor must be aware of the reason for the break, the student’s location, and his/her status at all times.  Allergic reactions can quickly escalate, becoming life-threatening without warning.  If the student requires oral antihistamines to treat a minor reaction, or is experiencing significant allergy symptoms, s/he will consider the fact that the cognitive impairment thus induced may invalidate the results of testing(16).

4)   The proctor must be prepared to recognize and respond to anaphylaxis by using an epinephrine autoinjector and then immediately calling 911 from the test site. Given that it is impossible to make the risk of anaphylaxis negligible, a responsible adult who has some knowledge how to recognize and respond to anaphylaxis must be present with the student.  During anaphylaxis, impairment can be so profound and so rapid that the student may not be competent to initiate treatment.  Delays in treatment—even just minutes—may result in death or permanent injury.  The student and her parents will provide education to the proctor to aid him/her in recognizing the warning signs of anaphylaxis (5, 14) and the correct use of an epinephrine autoinjector(15).  In the event of anaphylaxis, the student must be treated with epinephrine in situ and immediately transported to the nearest emergency room via EMS; delays in treatment may result in death or permanent injury, and persons experiencing severe anaphylaxis may rapidly become incapacitated and unable to initiate treatment. It is also extremely important that a person experiencing anaphylaxis not be moved to an upright position or allowed to walk or stand, as this can result in immediate cardiac arrest (17).   In the event of anaphylaxis, the student will clearly be unable to complete the examination; her scores should be invalidated and, if possible, s/he should be reseated to take the exam at a later date.


7. Establish the professional credentials of the evaluator:

Awesome Person, M.D.
Diplomate, American Board of Allergy and Immunology.







References:


1.   Nguyen-Luu NU, Ben-Shoshan M, et al. “Inadvertent exposures in children with peanut allergy.” Pediatr Allergy Immunol. 2012 Mar;23(2):134-140.

2.   Pumphrey RS. “Lessons for management of anaphylaxis from a study of fatal reactions.” Clin Exp Allergy. 2000;30 :1144– 1150

3.   Pumphrey RS, Roberts IS. “Postmortem findings after fatal anaphylactic reactions.” J Clin Pathol 2000; 53:273.

4.   Shah E, Pongracic J. “Food-induced anaphylaxis: who, what, why, and where?” Pediatr Ann. 2008; 37 (8):536-41.

5.   Sampson HA. “Anaphylaxis and emergency treatment.” Pediatrics.2003;111 :1601– 1608.


6.   Lieberman P, Nicklas RA, Oppenheimer J, et al. “The diagnosis and management of anaphylaxis practice parameter: 2010 update.” J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2010;126(3):477-480 e1-42.

7.   van der Zee T, Dubois A, Kerkhof M, et al. “The eliciting dose of peanut in double-blind, placebo-controlled food challenges decreases with increasing age and specific IgE level in children and young adults.” J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2011;128(5):1031-6. Epub 2011 Aug 31.

8.   Brown SGA, Mullins RJ, Gold MS. “Anaphylaxis: diagnosis and management.” Med J Aust 2006; 185 (5): 283-289. 

9.    Staal, M. Stress, “Cognition, and Human Performance: A Literature Review and Conceptual Framework,” (2004) NASA, Ames Research Center. Retrieved from www.human-factors.arc.nasa.gov April 3, 2012.

10.   Duncko, R., Johnson, L., Merikangas, K. et al. “Working memory performance after acute exposure to the cold pressor stress in healthy volunteers.” Neurobiology of Learning and Memory 2009;91, 377–381.

11.   Marklund B, Wilde-Larsson B, et al. “Adolescents' experiences of being food-hypersensitive: a qualitative study.” BMC Nursing 2007, 6:8.

12.    Steinberg L. “Risk Taking in Adolescence. What Changes, and Why?” Ann N Y Acad Sci 2004, 1021:51-58.

13.    Steinberg L: “Cognitive and affective development in adolescence.” TRENDS in Cognitive Sciences 2005, 9(2):69-74.

14.    Simons KJ, Simons FE. “Epinephrine and its use in anaphylaxis: current issues.” Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol. 2010; 10(4):354-361.

15.   “How to Use EpiPen.” www.epipen.com/how-to-use-epipen; Retrieved April 2, 2012.

16.   Walker S, Khan-Wasti S, et al. “Seasonal Allergic rhinitis is associated with a detrimental effect on examination performance in United Kingdom teenagers: Case control study.” J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2007; 120(2):381-7. Epub 2007 Jun 8.

17.     Pumphrey RS. “Fatal posture in anaphylactic shock.” J Allergy Clin Immunol.2003;112 :451– 452





Wow.  It's a baby review article!   :misspeak:   

Cheeky of me to provide this to the allergist?  Oh, sure.  It might be if we didn't know one another so well.  But odds are good that he's read most of those references himself anyway and will recognize them immediately.  (I don't think that I quoted him as an author anywhere... but he might be on the practice parameter.)

Fair to say that I don't think that the College Board can complain that they haven't been given more than adequate documentation.  LOL. ;D
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 03, 2012, 08:24:29 PM
I will now type up the original-- and then the revised version-- of the magical eligibility letter. 

Hopefully we can get that posted here so that others starting out with their schools can have a great example to work from.

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Carefulmom on April 03, 2012, 08:49:04 PM
CM Deux, just so you know, they are not allowed to eat in there.  I don`t think it will be that bad for your dd.  She would just need to clean her desk really well, maybe ask anyone who is passing out the test to wash hands or use wipes if she is worried about residue on the test papers.  You could probably sit outside the room and read for four hours (actually the test was more like 4 3/4 hours, because there were experimental questions) and thus eliminate needing an epi trained person.  I wouldn`t suggest that if this were an ongoing situation like a class, but it might make it easier for you.  I realize it is their legal responsibility to have an epi trained adult there, just saying it`s one morning out of her life and once you make them aware of her disability, I don`t think it will be that hard to get a few accomodations.  I wasn`t sure if you knew how strict they are about the eating.  It really is impossible to eat in there.  And no issue with bringing her meds and cell phone.  All the girls brought purses, tote bags, etc.  The kids were not allowed to access it during the exam (obviously).  I cannot imagine for the few accomodations that she will need that the testing people will give you a hard time.  Really it is just a few small things that she needs beyond what is normally allowed.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 03, 2012, 09:49:04 PM
Absolutely-- but-- the need itself is absolute, if you KWIM. 

Several diabetic families I know have handled it off the record, as well-- knowing that their kid was probably going to run high, and just figuring, well, better that than LOW... it's just one day...

but then I reconsidered when someone pointed out that they had initially done that, but needed to get accommodations for AP exams later, and then when the student retook the SAT with breaks as-needed (ie-- under better control) the scores told the story.  They were (seriously) about 20 points higher.

Given that this is going to be at a location that is unfamiliar, and a stressful situation to begin with (it is for everyone), I think it's only fair to DD for her to be able to step back and evaluate "is this just anxiety, or is my chest getting tight??" rather than trying to ignore a possible problem.  I realize that might not be such a big deal for many kids, and if I didn't think that anaphylaxis was a seriouos possibility, I wouldn't either.

DD really does have a lot of trouble in environments where people have been allowed to eat food over a long period of time, and she really does not always present with symptoms that (even to her) necessarily seem really obviously "allergic" in nature until she's more or less incapacitated.

  Sometimes that low level exposure just stays "annoying" and sometimes it doesn't.  I probably would just go with the flow and hope for the best (like my friends with diabetic kiddos) if we didn't have indicators that she might be in NMS range after the PSAT.  In her case, for that reason and that reason only, we do think that it is probably important for her to have as few impediments to success as possible. 

I'm sharing only because there really isn't ANYTHING on how to officially get accommodations from College Board for specific medical conditions other than diabetes, at least not that I found.  DD's 504 plan also doesn't really address any of this because when her school does state testing-- they come to our house to proctor, and they follow rules even when doing that (no eating allergens that morning, washing hands, etc.).  So they don't really assume duty of care for her, and therefore there isn't any need for most of those provisions (which would ordinarily be IN A 504 PLAN.)  Just wanted to clarify that.  With a comprehensive 504 plan and a simple physician's letter, it is quite straightforward, apparently.

 When the school counselor spoke with them and went over the above points, incidentally, the response was quite favorable in terms of this all being quite straightforward and reasonable in terms of what is being asked.   :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 03, 2012, 09:54:20 PM
Here, the standard is that NOTHING is allowed in the room but the students, the proctor, and the calculators and pencils basically-- at leat not without specific accommodations in place.  One friend's DD was hassled pretty hard about an insulin pump, for heaven's sakes.  I have also heard of proctors that bring in a 'snack' for themselves on the sly.   :-/ 

So yeah- mostly, it should be fine, as long as you have someone running things using common sense.  In reality, though, it's like hoping for rational thought from the TSA.  "Should" doesn't necessarily mean "will" without compulsion.  LOL.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: maeve on April 03, 2012, 10:44:07 PM
DD really does have a lot of trouble in environments where people have been allowed to eat food over a long period of time, and she really does not always present with symptoms that (even to her) necessarily seem really obviously "allergic" in nature until she's more or less incapacitated.

The room I was assigned to the first time I took the SAT was in the cafeteria.  That is always a possible location.  BTW, it was awful because the room was so wide open and then the proctor let someone in to use the soda machine so in the middle of the exam we had the noise of money going in the machine and the soda being dispensed.  The second time I took the SATs at a local prep school and we were in a classroom, but the proctor let the prep school kids return from breaks late even though the test had started again.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 03, 2012, 11:46:20 PM
Okay, this is really just sort of ancillary-- we have a 504 review planned and the counselor (who is brand new on the job, and I don't think has much experience with FA or other chronic medical conditions as a basis for being a QID) decided that the allergist's letter was "dated."

Well, fine.  We needed to get something current for the College Board anyway. (They prefer documentation which is within the same year as the first planned exam).

So we are getting an updated magic letter from Dr. Awesome for our 504 team and the school, too--  (Please note that this is the ADOLESCENT version of this document, which is admittedly a complete and total, no-wiggle-room-allowed, no-holds-barred, SLEDGEHAMMER of a document in support of 504 eligibility.)  My profound and eternal thanks to GailW and her DD for letting me see and tweak their original into this eventual form.   :heart:  I'll forever be paying that debt forward.  Truly.   :smooch: 


(DATE)

To Whom It May Concern:

  I have been asked by {CM DD}'s parents to provide medical information regarding {DD}’s allergies.  I understand that you need specific and current information that will be used to determine whether or not {DD} meets the criteria for disability under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (ADA and ADAA of 2008).  I believe that {DD} qualifies for this designation based upon her diagnosis and clinical history of life-threatening (anaphylactic) food allergy.

Anaphylaxis is defined as a systemic allergic reaction which may cause death or permanent disability.  At least 150 people die each year in the United States due to anaphylactic reactions to foods, most commonly to peanuts.  Below, I briefly describe the body systems affected during anaphylaxis:

Systems and Symptoms:

Skin and subcutaneous tissues: flushing, mouth itching and swelling of the lips, tongue, or mouth, and/or hives.

Gastrointestinal system: nausea, abdominal cramps, vomiting and diarrhea (if severe, can cause intravascular volume depletion and shock).

Respiratory system: sense of tightness/itching in the throat, hoarseness due to edema of the larynx (may close the airway), hacking cough, shortness of breath, and/or wheezing.

Cardiovascular system: “thready” pulse, decreased cardiac function, decrease in blood pressure which may lead to dizziness, loss of consciousness, shock, and possible cardiac arrest.


  {DD} has required emergent medical care for anaphylaxis on more than one occasion.  She has a history of rapidly progressing anaphylaxis involving the skin, gastrointestinal, respiratory, and cardiovascular systems.  Due to this reaction history {DD} is at elevated risk for fatal anaphylaxis.

{DD} was diagnosed with life-threatening food allergies at 11 months, following emergency medical care for peanut-induced anaphylaxis.  Since that time, she has also been diagnosed with life-threatening allergies to eggs and several tree nuts (almond, pistachio, cashew, etc.).  She has a clinical history of reactivity to ingestion of microscopic quantities of allergens, contact with allergens, and inhalation of allergens.  Some reactions have been atypically-presenting (without airway or skin features) and therefore very challenging to correctly identify in a timely fashion.  Possible anaphylaxis symptoms must be treated as a medical emergency.

For the purposes of a Section 504 designation, I attest that {DD}’s medical condition substantially and significantly affects the life functions of caring for herself, normal immune function, and eating.  Anaphylaxis can, when active, also substantially and significantly limit the life functions of breathing, talking, walking, normal cardiovascular function, thinking and performing manual tasks, among others.

There is no cure for food anaphylaxis.  Unlike other allergies for which treatment options include medications or immunotherapy (allergy shots), presently all such treatments for food allergy are considered investigational and high-risk.  There is no such approved treatment or device that can act as a mitigating measure for those who are anaphylactic to foods.  Regular maintenance medications do not eliminate the need to practice avoidance, nor does epinephrine or any other rescue medication or device necessarily resolve anaphylaxis or eliminate the need to seek additional emergent care.  Death or permanent disability is a possible outcome any time anaphylaxis is triggered.  Peanut is of particular concern since triggering doses may be very small and too variable to be reliably determined for an individual.  Therefore, total avoidance of allergenic foods is imperative.

Avoidance of all contact with food allergens (peanut, egg, and tree nuts) is the only way to avoid a potentially life-threatening allergic reaction.  Such avoidance is a highly complex task requiring excellent judgment and social skills, particularly when needs place a person in conflict with a peer group.  This is difficult for adolescents, whose executive skills are not yet mature and who may take unacceptably large risks or even hide/dismiss emergent symptoms in order to gain social acceptance with peers.   Adolescents must be strongly encouraged to advocate assertively for their needs as appropriate and guided toward good management decisions as they assume the responsibility for their food allergies.

Successful avoidance requires a comprehensive written accommodation plan in consultation with the patient, parents, and physician.    I consider {DD}’s parents; CM DH, Ph.D., and CM Ph.D., to be knowledgeable about the successful management of their daughter’s medical condition.

Sincerely,

 Awesome Person, M.D.
{additional fancy qualifications as he sees fit}



Obviously, there are significant elements there which include my daughter's specific allergens and her specific history.  It's probably also true that mentioning one's own qualifications is probably not necessary, but if you have a terminal degree, (particularly an MD or PhD) it probably doesn't hurt to put it out there since you're basically having the physician say that you are "EXPERTS" yourselves.   ;)  I've found that it can garner some street cred when it's sorely needed (as in negotiations with school staff over something that they don't feel like doing).

I'll post the original elementary aged one up in resources tomorrow. 

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: twinturbo on April 04, 2012, 01:12:04 AM
Thanks x 3 for posting all the letters. We'll be needing it.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 04, 2012, 08:49:32 AM
Off to the allergist via e-mail!   :thumbsup:

One word of warning before anyone lifts the entire document and plops it in front of an allergist to sign--
unless you have a relationship with that allergist which is: a) positive, b) constructive, c) collaborative, and d) VERY long-standing; such a document (complete with references) is likely to raise a LOT of questions with that allergist.  Questions about MSBP, to be blunt.  :misspeak:  That document is something that I wouldn't have presented to this allergist six years ago, even though I probably could have written it then, and even though I have a PhD in a relevant discipline which explains how I know some of that stuff, and why I'd be interested in particular quirks of pharmacology/cognitive research.


One final thing to note, also-- the neuroscience references that are included in that document (the large one with citations) are probably outside the scope of expertise for most allergists.  This may well include ours.  He and I have had a discussion about that, but the bottom line is that my expertise is official in that area.  What this means is that some allergists might not be comfortable with that portion of things, and ours might not either... but for effective consultation with someone who has a PhD in the relevant discipline (neuroscience) and therefore has the ability to examine the literature as an expert.

I wanted to mention that specifically, as the references used to support those points are-- um-- 'extrapolations' of more general research.  Not grossly so, no. I truly believe that any neuroscientist or cognitive-behavioral specialist would make the same conclusions without batting an eyelash.  Notice that I did not include a lot of predator-scent research there.  It's too big a leap, basically.  Foot-shock relates directly to learning/performance and it's a technique that has been used in the field for decades, so it is rock-solid in terms of being an accepted means of studying stress and fear and conditioned responses.

It's pretty obvious physiologically why anaphylaxis would induce cognitive impairment.  Too bad there isn't any literature to support that from an empirical side, but it's also obvious why not.   ;D  Here, we're going to induce anaphylaxis, measure blood flow with a fMRI while we ask you math SAT questions, okay?  Here's a five dollar gift card for your trouble.  LOL.  Yeah, NO.   (Can I be in the sham treatment group, please??)

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Carefulmom on April 04, 2012, 10:18:45 AM
CM Deux, I wasn`t suggesting that you blow off accomodations, just saying that a lot of it probably won`t be an issue.  But I agree, one never knows.  What if the proctor is eating?  I have not seen them have any issue at all with purses and tote bags.  They just have to stay under the desk.  Worse case scenario, the kids are required to put their purses and tote bags in the front of the room.  But they definitely need to know about your dd anyhow, because if she is having sypmtoms or maybe having symptoms, she won`t be able to talk to tell them if they don`t know about her allergies.  About the person whose scores went up with accomodations, SAT scores tend to go up anyhow with practice, so it is hard to know if the accomodations caused higher scores, or if the scores would have gone up without accomodations.  The average increase over time with multiple tests is over 200 points.  I think you probably don`t need an epi trained person IF you plan to sit outside the room.  And I forgot, we are not even talking SAT.  It`s PSAT, so less than 4 hours---I think more like 2 hours?  I actually don`t recall.  Dd has taken so many tests, they all start to run together, lol.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 04, 2012, 10:45:17 AM
Oh, yes, I know that you weren't. :)
Yeah, not sure if the point difference in that anecdote was about blood glucose or repetition.  No way to know, but the young man's perception was that it was blood sugar related. 

The PSAT is about 3 h including breaks.  You'd better believe that I'm right outside... and I'll make that clear when we arrange a testing site and when we speak to the proctor the morning of.

The nice thing about doing this through the College Board (as opposed to ACT) is that you really only have to go through the application process ONCE.

Just once, and with approval, the student has it already in-hand for AP exams, PSAT, SAT, etc.  I'm not sure if it carries over to ETS exams or not, but clearly for college-bound kids, it really makes sense to go to the trouble. 

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Carefulmom on April 04, 2012, 11:04:23 AM
Oh, yes, I know that you weren't. :)
Yeah, not sure if the point difference in that anecdote was about blood glucose or repetition.  No way to know, but the young man's perception was that it was blood sugar related. 

The PSAT is about 3 h including breaks.  You'd better believe that I'm right outside... and I'll make that clear when we arrange a testing site and when we speak to the proctor the morning of.

The nice thing about doing this through the College Board (as opposed to ACT) is that you really only have to go through the application process ONCE.

Just once, and with approval, the student has it already in-hand for AP exams, PSAT, SAT, etc.  I'm not sure if it carries over to ETS exams or not, but clearly for college-bound kids, it really makes sense to go to the trouble.

Right, and given that there is no local school that she belongs to, they really don`t know about her.  When dd takes AP tests at her school, her friends are there (epi trained), school nurse is there who knows all about her, her epi trained teacher is there, it makes it so much easier.  For PSAT it was at her school also.  SAT was not at her school and she did not know anyone.  But she is not as contact sensitive as your dd.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 09, 2012, 12:11:50 PM
Ack.... the fun just never ends.

School counselor (the one who is new on the job?) has apparently decided (??) that this meeting calls for a complete REVIEW OF ELIGIBILITY.


Excuse me??!!!   :rant: :paddle:   No.  It does NOT.

Hopefully doctor's note will disabuse them of that particular notion in a hurry, but I'm kind of disturbed that they decided that ELIGIBILITY needs to be determined again. 

I've asked for clarification on this particular point, in fact. 


Getting the sense that I'm not really dealing with the "A" team, here-- I've now had two different times given to us for the meeting... (by the same person, no less, and the person who is SUPPOSEDLY spearheading the meeting, our 504 Coord, who is also new to the job this year...  )

Call me cynical, but I'm a bit suspicious about this.  It seems to me that "504-C" and "us" isn't exactly a valid "504-TEAM" in the first place, and that could well be the default if there is 'confusion' about the meeting time.  Admittedly, the NEW time is better than the original for DD... and the most likely explanation is, er-- less-than-stellar organizational capability on the part of the 504-C. 

And the bonus here is that the 504 C e-mailed me twice this morning;  a) once to let me know that she will be "out of the office" for the remainder of the day, and b) the second time to give me the meeting time (in conflict with the e-mail re: the meeting time from a week ago, recall).

Gaaaaaaa.  I caught the e-mails almost immediately (within ten minutes) and responded seeking clarification about meeting PURPOSE and also TIME.  No answer.  New meeting time is first thing tomorrow morning.  So no way to clarify it at this point, and nobody to ask.   :disappointed:



So I'm e-mailing the school COUNSELOR (different person than 504C) by forwarding the 504C's second e-mail to me along with the following note:
Quote
{Counselor firstname},

I'm sending this to you since {504C firstname} is apparently out for the rest of the day and didn't respond to my inquiry before she left.

  Do you have any idea why this has become an eligibility (as opposed to "review") meeting?  Eligibility should not be in question given the nature of {DD}'s disability.  What have I missed here?

Do you know which time is correct?  {504C firstname}'s earlier webmail had us meeting at {time}, and this one indicates {earlier time}.

Thanks,

{My firstname}
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 09, 2012, 01:42:16 PM
OH, great.

Autoreply indicates that Counselor isn't necessarily available today, either.  <teeth gnashing>
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: ajasfolks2 on April 09, 2012, 04:14:16 PM
There is some good news, at least unofficially!

When the school counselor spoke with someone at the College Board, they agreed that (based on our no-holds-barred outlay of daily impact and justifications for accommodation) that this all seemed quite straightforward and reasonable.

Keeping my fingers crossed that it still seems that way after next week, but that is at least some good news.


I just wanted to point out (knowing that CM knows this, but just in case others don't, or get trapped by verbiage) -- the counselor and the "someone" at the College Board may have used the word "reasonable" in their initial assessment and response, but it is CRUCIAL that always the letters from parents/student and physicians stress the exact language of Section 504 which is that the accommodations be "NECESSARY AND APPROPRIATE" for the student.  I would always make that distinction and not let the other try to push back against something as being not "reasonable" . . .

"Reasonable" applies in ADA language for a workplace . . . remember that these accommodations in this thread are for education/school related so NOT bound by subjective test of "reasonable" (or refusal as "unreasonable") so far as the letter of the law. 

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: ajasfolks2 on April 09, 2012, 04:15:47 PM
Spelling out (in writing, bullet-by-bullet, with physician sign off) the "whys" for "Necessary" and "Appropriate" for each and every accommodation may be necessary in some instances.

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: ajasfolks2 on April 09, 2012, 04:20:15 PM
. . . and CM, as to the most recent developments, GGA!!!! 

"Not 'A' Team" is nicely put . . . you're clearly going to need some extra patience for meeting.

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 09, 2012, 04:56:36 PM
Ask how freaked I was when the receptionist initially couldn't locate Dr. Awesome's packet of letters on letterhead.  <hair on fire>  Tense twenty minutes, that was.  LOL.

RE: "reasonable" accommodations.  I'm pretty sure that College Board is not bound by Section 504, but by Title I(?) or is it III (?) I always get those confused. 

ANYway.  I'm pretty sure that because this is technically extracurricular and not "sponsored" by the school itself... and not "required" by any high school, for that matter, that this comes under place of public accommodation.

Therefore, DOE-OCR isn't overseeing such things, and Letter to Zirkel doesn't apply.  "Fundamental nature of the activity" and "reasonable alterations to practices, policies, and procedures" is the standard.  This is sort of a no-brainer to me... that PHYSICAL accommodations ought really to be easy to both understand and to implement, since they clearly do not confer anything in the way of unfair advantage (unlike, say +100% time which most certainly can).  The reality is that there are a lot of families willing to be unscrupulous about securing unfair advantage on this kind of high-stakes test, though, and anything that looks "odd" is going to get additional scrutiny, and the reflexive response from College Board is "no, you didn't demonstrate need" when they are confused about anything.

It's educational, of course, and the reality is that it IS a de facto requirement at this point in time for any child not destined for the military or unskilled labor post-secondary... and obviously anyone with a medical disability isn't eligible for the former in the first place.  ANYWAY.

  But I saw definite language from both College Board and ACT that indicate that they are under no particular obligation under ADA section 504 or under IDEA.  They are NOT obligated for LRE or FAPE, and they are not obligated to anything more than, say, an employer or business owner is in making accommodation for the disabled.  The standard of what they must provide and why is different from the underlying spirit of Section 504.


I'm still more than a bit miffed over the "eligibility" meeting tomorrow.  Believe me, I do intend to address that fairly directly.  That is INAPPROPRIATE.  Period.  A "review" of data supporting eligibility as part of a regular 504 review?  Fine-- probably a good idea in light of the information that the College Board is seeking/apparently wanting.  I don't like the whiff of "we can hold another eligibility meeting any time we feel it's warranted" though.  The school isn't qualified to offer opinion on change in eligibility, frankly.  If we-- or her physician-- feel that the qualifying condition has changed, it is for US to let THEM know-- that is in part what periodic review is about, n'est pas? 

Grrr.  Clearly momma needs one of these today and tomorrow:   :bonking:
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 09, 2012, 05:01:12 PM
If ANYTHING were ever a CLEAR, CLEAR reason to get a 504 plan in place no matter how well things are covered by school policy, though, this is it.  One of the easiest ways to be denied by the College Board is to have no 504 plan, or one that has been active less than a year.

I just hope that spurs someone to act while their child is still in elementary-- this stuff really matters later on in terms of history of documented accommodations and longevity of official qualification under 504.   :yes:  It will matter in college, too. 
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Arkadia on April 09, 2012, 08:46:33 PM
I just entered this thread and am flabbergasted.

Yes, we've "sought" out these official accommodations with the College Board (that term is on the letterhead we received without difficulty and in a timely fashion and with nothing more than a simple phone call to the Special Education Services Coordinator/Director at our high school.)

I could ask her to call you if you want?

Not a squirm, not a wiggle, not a blip. Easy Peasy.

I was told to keep the letter in a safe place as it would be used throughout his HS career.

I didn't go to testing with him, but he tested for the PSAT in a separate room with one other student and a proctor. The proctor was a regular aide from the Highschool itself. He was allowed to have his phone turned off in his backpack, and they allowed calculators on the math portion (as ALL students are), he kept his epi pen on him ("of course!" to quote him, he's sick of me badgering him while I type this), and not a bit of food there. He had a break and a snack lunch he brought.

"what did the other kid bring?"

"I don't know, I don't remember, I don't care."

Teens, huh?

anyways, they were highly aware of his allergy, trained to use the epi, and familiar with the school itself and the students. It was a nearly private location, and no difficulties noted what. so. ever. All arranged by special education services and without any haranguing by moi'.

let me know if you need further assistance. this is routine stuff. (no slight to you, just skimmed over some of what you are reporting back with revolving around difficulty getting accommodations.) They worked from his IEP and maybe the issue is here you haven't formally laid out accommodations for H.S.? If I remember, I didn't have to negotiate eligibility again for H.S., but they did request recent allergy testing at the time. <shrug>

Anyways, yes, we have a letter of accommodation and everything went smoothly. Son didn't give it a second thought. They directed him without incident to a alternate location as well, virtually around the corner from the room where testing was being held. No problems.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: yelloww on April 09, 2012, 08:51:25 PM
CM, I've tried to explain the need for the 504 long term to he principal and school nurse here. They think I'm over the top for my long term planning. They think I'm  :insane: for planning for hs and college accommodations well before he's there. This thread is exactly why I plan the way I do.

Hope they pull their heads out tomorrow!
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 09, 2012, 09:04:35 PM
I don't mean to make this out to be a bigger deal than it is-- in my daughter's view of things, that is, or in practical difficulty in implementation.  After tomorrow, I anticipate that the College Board will hand us our magic letter in about three weeks' time.  Truly.



There are a few factors at work, basically, which make this a little more complicated than Carefulmom's of Ark's situations:

a) student is not currently covered by duty of care of any local educational provider (this was easier for Ark and Carefulmom because their kids are already in a B&M setting, and therefore it seemed seamless enough to everyone concerned to have those things carry over without a lot of thought)-- this can be a factor for any homeschooled, extremely rural, or virtually schooled student... or, for that matter, for any student that attends a very small private school or an alternative school of any kind.  If the test location isn't your child's regular school, there will be hoops to jump.  The PSAT is the 'scholarship' test, and host schools are not obligated to offer outside students seats.  (It is different from the AP and SAT's that way, where there are pretty much unlimited seats for any who want them.)  So her 504 plan and the sought accommodations do not matchy-matchy.  This is a red flag for the College Board and ACT both.  A bigger red flag, of course, is not having the disability documented to begin with; folks who have homeschooled exclusively or done things informally may really find themselves having to go to tremendous lengths (thus the specifics that I've provided, which are rather sledgehammer-like in nature...)


b) clueless new-to-the-job administrators/sp-ed staffers.  They don't know FA's, they don't know my kid, they don't know what they are doing, basically...  :-/ This is one that can be in play for pretty much anyone, at any time.  As we all know.

c) tight time-line.  My preference would have been to begin this process about ten months out.  That would have meant:  a) no special doctor's appt., b) no special 504 meeting, and c) no worries re: how fast the College Board turns things around (6-8 weeks).  That ship sailed when they bumped my DD from 9th to 11th grade officially in June, and we've had to scramble in a couple of different venues since then as we try to dot i's that would have been made in the sophomore year in the ordinary course of events. 

Plus, I figured that there is probably some value in putting this out there--
because it it is NOT out there anywhere for food allergy.  There are others behind us.   :heart:

Finally, I'm a dot-all-the-i's-and-cross-all-the-t's, obsessive kind of person when it comes to documentation.  I like the sure thing, so I'm willing to go a little over the top (in terms of information overload, I mean-- not exaggeration of anything, which this is not).   :yes:
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Carefulmom on April 09, 2012, 10:36:08 PM
CM Deux, dd did not take her SAT at her home school.  Actually she did not take her SAT subject tests last year at her home school either.  Both times she was at a school where she did not know anyone--- no teachers, no kids.  However, she is not as contact sensitive as your dd.  She brought her epi with her (tote bags and backpacks allowed), no eating allowed in the room so no worries about airborne issues.  She brought a couple of wipes to clean the desk.  They actually knew nothing about her.   All the kids were allowed cell phones as long as they were off and put away.

 
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Carefulmom on April 09, 2012, 10:40:40 PM
Also, about the PSAT and scholarships, in this day and age, there is very little money given out based on PSATs, almost none.  You have to be in the top fraction of 1% (don`t recall if it was 0.1% or even less) and the amount was about $1000.  However, this may be California specific.  You may want to check on your state.  If there is that little riding on your dd`s results, she can relax about the test.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 10, 2012, 12:10:49 AM
I don't really expect that she'll be concerned about the $$, which has never been enough to really get too excited about, honestly...  it's more about the prestige of being named a NMS finalist, which is a pretty big deal on a CV.  So it's not really 'pressure' in terms of performance for her, since we'll be sending her to college either way, YK?  It's more just relax and see how well you can do.  She's very, very good at standardized testing.  Very.  She kind of... um... enjoys them.   :misspeak:


Just wanted to mention that our allergist happily provided BOTH documents on letterhead... he even copyedited my bad typing and corrected some formatting on my reference list.   ;D  He also added "asthma" to fatality risk in both documents.  We just :heart: that man.  I just wish that I could clone him, because truly, everyone with food allergies deserves an allergist this great. 
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: joanna5 on April 10, 2012, 01:10:28 PM
Also, about the PSAT and scholarships, in this day and age, there is very little money given out based on PSATs, almost none.  You have to be in the top fraction of 1% (don`t recall if it was 0.1% or even less) and the amount was about $1000.  However, this may be California specific.  You may want to check on your state.  If there is that little riding on your dd`s results, she can relax about the test.

That's true. I think I got $2000 a year from it.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Carefulmom on April 11, 2012, 02:22:28 PM
Also, about the PSAT and scholarships, in this day and age, there is very little money given out based on PSATs, almost none.  You have to be in the top fraction of 1% (don`t recall if it was 0.1% or even less) and the amount was about $1000.  However, this may be California specific.  You may want to check on your state.  If there is that little riding on your dd`s results, she can relax about the test.

That's true. I think I got $2000 a year from it.

I think it is even less now.  I am guessing that your $2000 was before you had kids.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 11, 2012, 03:32:16 PM
I think that NMSC offers $1000 now, last I checked.  So no, definitely nothing too substantial in the face of tuition and fees in the 10-20K range annually.  It's definitely more about the prestige than finances. 
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 12, 2012, 12:27:50 PM
Ack.  GGA.  Not the "A" team has just taken on a whole new dimension of absurdity.  I'm clearly dealing with Abbott and Costello here.


:banghead:

More later.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Ra3chel on April 12, 2012, 01:56:50 PM
Also, about the PSAT and scholarships, in this day and age, there is very little money given out based on PSATs, almost none.  You have to be in the top fraction of 1% (don`t recall if it was 0.1% or even less) and the amount was about $1000.  However, this may be California specific.  You may want to check on your state.  If there is that little riding on your dd`s results, she can relax about the test.

That varies tremendously from state to state and school to school. Being a NMF paid more than a quarter of my (private) college tuition; this was 2000-2004. If I'd gone to a state school in FL, I'd have gotten a full ride on that basis alone.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Carefulmom on April 12, 2012, 02:49:49 PM
Also, about the PSAT and scholarships, in this day and age, there is very little money given out based on PSATs, almost none.  You have to be in the top fraction of 1% (don`t recall if it was 0.1% or even less) and the amount was about $1000.  However, this may be California specific.  You may want to check on your state.  If there is that little riding on your dd`s results, she can relax about the test.

That varies tremendously from state to state and school to school. Being a NMF paid more than a quarter of my (private) college tuition; this was 2000-2004. If I'd gone to a state school in FL, I'd have gotten a full ride on that basis alone.

Oh....so long ago.  Times have changed unfortunately.  Big change in the economy since 2000-2004.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 12, 2012, 03:00:52 PM
Ack.  GGA.  Not the "A" team has just taken on a whole new dimension of absurdity.  I'm clearly dealing with Abbott and Costello here.


:banghead:

More later.
Good golly, the draft that they sent had all kinds of dorky changes, most of them completely out of left field and unrelated to anything discussed in the 504 review meeting from Tuesday. 


The e-mail that I fired off first thing this morning... (redacted, of course)...

Quote
Abbott and Costello;

Briefly, my concerns regarding the new draft document dated April 2012 are:

a) Grade level. I'm not clear on precisely when this document is intended to take effect, but it is quite important to us that {DD}'s grade level remain "9" through the end of this academic year. She will otherwise lose an additional year of eligibility with some particular extracurricular activities, and because of her multiple radical accelerations, she's already lost several.

b) Impairment and Life Activities Impacted-- There are some problems with the verbiage in the impairment description. I'm sorry, but I'm a little particular about these statements, and I know that her allergist is as well. "{DD} has been DIAGNOSED WITH AND HAS A HISTORY OF severe food allergies (anaphylaxis). When EXPERIENCING ANAPHYLAXIS, she is profoundly impaired in all life activities. Her HISTORY AND DIAGNOSIS (multiple severe food allergy, asthma) places her at elevated risk of fatal anaphylaxis."

{the caps there were to fix new and incredibly screwed up verbiage that demonstrated a pretty profound lack of understanding of the nature of LTFA}

Secondly, the passage of ADAA in 2008 has resulted in a need to consider episodic conditions, meaning that the life-activities listed under qualification must be those which would be impaired "if the condition were active." Anaphylaxis very definitely impairs pretty much everything on that list. It's hard to imagine a more pervasive set of impairments that full body shut-down of multiple organs. Episodic? Certainly-- and until 2008, the items currently listed would have been complete and sufficient under the law. This is not in compliance with current legislation, however.

Finally, under "Breathing" in the notes, this information is not correct. {DD}'s asthma is episodic and quite well-controlled. What *can* limit her ability to maintain a regular study schedule for weeks is the course of treatment following anaphylaxis. The medications taken to prevent relapse or death can impact executive function and cognitive skills for an extended period of time.

c) Curriculum Accommodations and/or Modifications: the verbiage on the provision of wet-wipes has been changed from "{school} will provide" to "parents will provide." This is incorrect. {National} has been through this particular accommodation (presumably with legal) and it MUST not be in writing that *we* are obligated to additional expense for {DD}'s participation. We may *choose* to provide wipes, or to donate them. (And we often do.) But we cannot be obligated to do so because it is a violation of FAPE.

d) Curriculum Accommodations and/or Modifications: if you've seen my note from late Tuesday, I still believe that an addendum regarding "daily work" and the environment that is required might be added. Yes, I know that the school is obligated to do very little there, but I think that it is a missing piece for the College Board, since familiarity with virtual schooling may well be somewhat fuzzy for outsiders.

e) Curriculum Accommodations and/or Modifications: "testing" in the context of curriculum accommodations and/or modifications cannot, in my own understanding, include modifications to the practices, policies, and procedures of those agencies not affiliated with {school} in pursuit of meeting {DD}'s educational needs to the same degree as her unaffected peers. I'm not convinced that colleges and universities, much less the College Board, can be covered here. Perhaps for an AP examingation, yes. I feel that it would be better to indicate the basic NEEDS which must be met routinely for all assessment, and to explain how those needs are currently met by us. That is, we as partners supply an allergen-controlled environment at all times (materials and environment), and parents alone supply any necessary oversight and medical evaluation.

The paired statements in d) and e) do not overstep the bounds of the family-school partnership. I am concerned that the current statement in the draft *does* do so. We can't dictate conditions to external agencies without input from them, and I have concerns that this current document may do that. It also includes accommodations which are not in place at all, and won't ever be, given the nature of virtual schooling. This doesn't meet the standard of "necessary" in the context of FAPE and LRE with {SCHOOL}. Ergo, I'm not sure that it properly has a place in her 504 plan. Adjusting the verbiage so that it better matches the terminology in the document submitted to the College Board is fine, but we're getting the cart in front of the horse, here, I think. The 504 plan is about {DD}'s educational access via {School}, so accommodations needed from the College Board shouldn't be driving accommodations in this document. Technically, since {Another magically appearing accommodation that has been in place for years but was never in writing} isn't about disability accommodation but about GT accommodation, I'm not sure that even that belongs in here, unless we are going to roll gifted needs into this document. I'm fine with that approach, though the more obvious route to GT accommodations is via an IEP.

f) Notes: {DD}'s percentage hasn't been %% in several years (if ever), at least not until sometime yesterday. It most properly isn't NOW, either, if not for the fairly zealous application of "temporary zeros" by one teacher in particular, and on a single assignment which is not yet a week overdue and requires us to make a trip to check out materials at a local research university. {please note that there ARE no 'official' due-dates for assignments anyway in DD's school given the way it operates} We've had to fit this trip in around her other academic and extracurricular obligations and numerous medical appointments, and our family's other obligations. I think it is fair to see how that might take additional time. I am not at all happy about this percentage being unfairly reported in this document. If the College Board is going to see this, then let them see reality, at least. That percentage is continuously something like {+10% higher percentage}, a fact that her transcripts reflect much more accurately. The current statement is therefore misleading and also potentially deeply damaging to {DD}'s credibility. {Identifyin statements} and there is nothing borderline about her qualifying academic performance in earning that honor. I realize that neither of you is especially familiar with {DD} as a student at this time, and also that for many students, such an average would be cause for delight-- but I noted that statement with horror. I suspect that {teacher} would be equally horrified to know what potential trouble a single temporary zero inadvertently caused.

Do we need an additional meeting to discuss this? Hopefully my explanations for each item above make sense. I apologize for the length of this message, but I wanted to be very clear about my objections and the reasons for each.

Thank you for your continued hard work on this document,

CM





Following that, walked Costello through the document on the phone-- line-by-line.  Thank goodness DH was here and able to run DD to her medical appt. on time.     Costello agreed with me once he realized that I wasn't looking to cherry pick additional accommodations-- and that I understood why language about delegation, etc. should be in there somewhere, since that means they won't be obligated to hire a paramedic to have her seated for the SAT if she has to test with them.  He and I got along fine, though he is still learning about LTFA as a qualifying disability.   Costello is apparently the brains of the operation here.  <sigh>  Too bad Costello's job title doesn't have "504" in it anywhere.   :misspeak:  We're at Abbott's mercy, I fear, and that is not a good thing. 
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on April 12, 2012, 03:01:33 PM
Lesson here is that staffing changes can rapidly screw up a very good 504 document if you aren't vigilant.   :insane:
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: ajasfolks2 on April 12, 2012, 04:22:14 PM
Thank you so very much for this EXCELLENT and timely thread!!

Appreciated the corrections and nuance as to CollegeBoards, etc and 504 v. ADA & Title I/II!!

If nothing else -- my kids got as benefit from their time in B&M school:  504s on record.

 ;D

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on June 25, 2012, 10:14:24 AM
Gaaaaaaaa!!!!!

After nine-- count them, N.I.N.E. weeks, I now am the proud(?) possessor of a "case number" with College Board, who has still done a big fat NOTHING with this application.

GGA.

So the CSR that I spoke with this fine morning has...

submitted a flag for IMMEDIATE DECISION...

Yeah, I have my misgivings about that, too, but she assured me that they are "familiar with all disabilities"  (ohhhh... reeeeeeally??  You mean all the "real" ones, don't you?? auuuuuuuughhhhh.... greeeeeeeaaaat...) and that this won't result in an automatic 'yeah, never heard of it... uhhhhh-- NO,' verdict.

I'm just beside myself.  Naturally, all of my school's support staff is gone-gone-gone until mid-August, so if this comes back "no," then I'm completely onm my own to figure it out.  Well, me and the doc, I suppose.

Actually, in light of the foot-dragging inanity involving the 504C and the completely unecessary re-write of DD's 504 plan for this purpose, hey, maybe that wouldn't be such a bad thing, no??

 ~)
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: yelloww on June 26, 2012, 02:41:59 PM
So if it is immediate decision, then you should know today, correct??
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on June 26, 2012, 03:00:34 PM
I was told that I "will have a letter within one week."

The gist was that I need to wait until then to bug them again.

Now, you know me.  I'm going to be calling them again tomorrow morning bright and early, since I must have misunderstood that part of things...   ;D
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: twinturbo on June 26, 2012, 04:17:55 PM
Lol. I love making those type of calls.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on June 27, 2012, 03:08:44 PM
Okay--

Approved for:

a) breaks as needed (with clock stopped)

b) snacks/medications available to student at all times.

NOT approved for "individual testing" which is what our school counselor had wanted to apply for (I'd argued that the first accommodation basically amounts to the same thing, which was just confirmed by College Board's CSR).

DD will be in a room by herself, with a proctor, and will have her medications available to her at all times, and can stop the test AT ANY TIME to evaluate symptoms.


WIN!   :thumbsup:

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: DJMom on June 28, 2012, 11:04:17 AM

That is awesome!  Great job!
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on May 05, 2014, 09:23:00 PM
bumping for myself
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on May 05, 2014, 09:35:05 PM
The form for the ACT, to be submitted at the time of registration (note in reality on the pdf there are exactly two lines to explain your  disability and accommodations requested with enough detail.  Two.

CM was this form available two years ago when you went through this? 


DS will be taking the ACT soon at a school that is not his--and not even one he's been at a speech tournament at, so he's not familiar with it. 



Explain your disability and clearly state the accommodations you are requesting with enough detail so we can make
arrangements with the test center.__________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
(C) Accommodati ons Requested
If you would like to request extended time, do not submit this application. Instead, complete the Extended Time Application for
National Testing at www.actstudent.org/regist/disab/.
❏ Wheelchair accessibility, Test at a table instead of a desk
❏ Large-type testing booklet and answer document (the testing staff will transfer answers from the large-print answer
document). The large-type booklet is 18 point font.
❏ Marking answers in the test booklet (the examinee will have to complete his or her name, address, and other personal
information). The examinee may watch the testing staff transfer the answers after testing is complete.
❏ Permission for food/drink in the testing room
❏ Permission for diabetics to bring diabetic supplies/wear insulin pump
❏ Stop-the-clock breaks (the examinee will test in a separate room)
❏ Seating near the front of the room
❏ Written copy of the spoken instructions
❏ Visual notification of start, time remaining, and stop times
❏ Sign Language Interpreter, directions only. Examinee is responsible to bring his or her sign language interpreter.
May not be a relative. ACT will pay the sign language interpreter.
❏ Other ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
(D) Student/Parent/Legal Guardian Signat ures
(Form cannot be processed without signatures.) I verify the information on this form is accurate to the best of my knowledge. I understand that any
documentation provided to ACT will be kept confidential, will be used solely to determine eligibility and will not become part of my score record.
Signature: Examinee _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Parent, if examinee is under 18 _________________________________________________________________________________________________




Adding links:

http://www.actstudent.org/regist/disab/

National Standard Time with Accommodations
http://www.actstudent.org/regist/disab/opt1.html
Request this only if you can test at a regularly scheduled national test center under standard time limits and use either a regular type (10-pt.) or large type (18-pt.) test booklet, but require accommodations due to your disability. All scores achieved through National Testing are reported as "National." No details about any accommodations provided are reported.

Examples include:

assignment to a wheelchair-accessible room
large type test booklet (18-pt.)
marking responses in the test booklet
permission for diabetics to eat snacks in the test room

You must register for your preferred test date by the registration deadline. If you register online, print a copy of your admission ticket and mail it along with all of the following information in a written request. If you register by mail, include all of the following information in a written request with your completed registration folder and payment.

-Your name, mailing address, and phone number.
-The test option and test date you are requesting.
-The name, city, state, and 6-digit code for each of the test center choices you requested when you registered online or marked in Block N of your registration folder.
-Explain your disability and clearly state the accommodations you are requesting with enough detail so we can make arrangements with the test center.
-Enclose written documentation from your school describing in detail the accommodations you normally receive in school.
-The name and phone number of a school official familiar with your current test accommodations.
-Send all materials to ACT, Attn: National Standard Time with Accommodations, PO Box 168, Iowa City, IA,  52243-0168, postmarked by the registration deadline for your preferred test date. Requests postmarked after the regular deadline, but received by the late deadline, will be processed. Forms received after the late deadline will be processed for the next test date.

Note: In order to provide the approved accommodations, ACT may not be able to assign you to the test center shown on your admission ticket. If this happens, you will need to print a new admission ticket from your ACT Web account.

If you want to test again with the same previously approved accommodations, you may re-register through your ACT Web account or by calling 319.337.1270 (phone fee applies).

Because advance arrangements are necessary, students trying to test standby cannot request accommodations.

If necessary, ACT will contact you or your high school for additional information. If accommodations are approved, ACT will make arrangements for you with the test center.


http://www.actstudent.org/regist/disab/chart.html
Supporting documentation required:
If first diagnosed within last 3 years, complete documentation required.
Copy of test accommodations pages from most current IEP, Section 504 Plan, or official accommodations plan. If plan has been in place less than 3 years, complete documentation required.
If no current IEP, Section 504, or accommodations plan, include exceptions information and complete documentation specified on request form.
Do not register online or complete a registration folder.  OOPS--We did this.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on May 05, 2014, 09:37:48 PM
DS' APUSH exam is next week, and though admistered by the CB, it is at his school, and we didn't have to fill out the form at the CB site.  For his AP exams:

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on May 05, 2014, 10:14:43 PM
Okay---this is WAAAAAAAY easier for the ACT than the SAT.  GGA. 

CM may have put these links earlier, but I'm putting these here for my convenience:

http://student.collegeboard.org/services-for-students-with-disabilities
http://professionals.collegeboard.com/testing/ssd/application/eligible/requirements
http://professionals.collegeboard.com/testing/ssd/application/guide
http://professionals.collegeboard.com/testing/ssd/application/guide/guidelines


So there is no way he can take the June test on a lark--with accommodations, that is. This shows the dates for the current academic year, but I'm putting them here anyway to give reference for the future. I had no idea . . . .

2013-2014 Test DatesAccommodations Request and Documentation (Where Required) Must Be Received by:
SAT® and SAT Subject Tests™
October 5, 2013 October 6
August 16, 2013
PSAT/NMSQT®
October 16 and 19, 2013
August 28, 2013
SAT and SAT Subject Tests
November 2, 2013
September 13, 2013
SAT and SAT Subject Tests
December 7, 2013
October 18, 2013
SAT and SAT Subject Tests
January 25, 2014
December 6, 2013
SAT
March 8, 2014
January 17, 2014
SAT and SAT Subject Tests
May 3, 2014
March 14, 2014
Advanced Placement Program® (AP®)
May 5–9, 12–16, 2014
February 21, 2014
SAT® and SAT Subject Tests™
June 7, 2014
April 18, 2014




Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on May 07, 2014, 12:18:51 PM
CM was this form available two years ago when you went through this? 


Not that I recall-- and I would definitely have looked.  As I noted up-thread, one of the more compelling reasons to go through what College Board puts you through is that the accommodations from them are forever-- and apply to PSAT, AP, SAT, and may transfer to ETS exams like the GRE.

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on May 10, 2014, 12:37:31 PM
Okay, for the ACT, we just had to submit that little form (we created a  fillable form of the pdf and had to create new fields to fit everything) and a copy of his 504 dated this past fall (I couldn't find a copy of the one that was revised in January :misspeak: ).  I also enclosed a copy of his latest ImmunoCAP results from January just for grins--to make sure there was no doubt.  His 504 says status was given based on 504 from previous school, and I didn't want there to be any question that it was needed.

What we asked for. 
--he be able to have two autoinjectors on his person during testing
--food free room, including the proctor (of course, if another student's accommodations include food, we fully understand)
--the proctor have a working, charged cell phone to use in case of emergency
--if DS thinks he's having a reaction, he has the ability to leave the room, administer medication and to contact 911 and/or his parents. 
--he not be singled out by the proctor of anyone else for his accommodations
--he be allowed to enter the room early to wipe down his desk before the other students enter


I don't think we'll get the last one. But it's not like his desk or anything else is wiped down in school.  But in school, it's in his 504 that he is able to move/change places if he thinks his location is unsafe. 

We didn't ask for someone there to administer because the school is 30 minutes away, actually down the street from where we lived last year.  Either DH or I will probably just hang out there. Also, DS doesn't have someone else who can administer with him all the time everywhere.  Unless he's passed out, he should be able to self-administer. If he can't, DH or I will be there. 

I mailed it by the first deadline, also the deadline for registration.  This is kind of funny--like "Send it by the registration deadline, but if you don't, we'll still process it, unless it's too late."

Quote
Send all materials to ACT, Attn: National Standard Time with Accommodations, PO Box 168, Iowa City, IA,  52243-0168, postmarked by the registration deadline for your preferred test date. Requests postmarked after the regular deadline, but received by the late deadline, will be processed. Forms received after the late deadline will be processed for the next test date.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on May 22, 2014, 04:21:10 PM

What we asked for. 
--he be able to have two autoinjectors on his person during testing
--food free room, including the proctor (of course, if another student's accommodations include food, we fully understand)
--the proctor have a working, charged cell phone to use in case of emergency
--if DS thinks he's having a reaction, he has the ability to leave the room, administer medication and to contact 911 and/or his parents. 
--he not be singled out by the proctor of anyone else for his accommodations
--he be allowed to enter the room early to wipe down his desk before the other students enter




What we got. Hmmmm. I don't think he wants a room by himself.

(http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b205/McCobbre/Mobile%20Uploads/05C800A4-AFD7-4BDE-A46D-8FBE6D11D470_zpsdkhwqc17.jpg)
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: yelloww on May 22, 2014, 05:31:05 PM
Maybe they so the single room as part of the no food accommodation? I'd love to take tests w no one else there! My be it's not a bad thing. No distractions.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on May 22, 2014, 06:21:08 PM
They have to, Mac-- because the nature of the disability is such that he has to have the ability to stop the clock to evaluate symptoms, right?

Same with T1D-- "clocks stopped, breaks as needed."  It mean (de facto ) individual testing.

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on May 22, 2014, 08:31:27 PM
But you know, I didn't request the clocks stopped thing. I thought about it, but he said he wanted to be in a room with others.

He is not testing at his school--actually testing where we lived last year because it was the closest by the time he registered. But if he takes it again and at his HS, he really, really won't want to be singled out like this.

I think it would be interesting to take it solo. But then I wonder if he can decline an accommodation.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: daisy madness on May 23, 2014, 07:20:36 PM
How is he feeling about these accommodations?  Is he ok with this?  If not, does the paper say anything about an appeal? 
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on May 23, 2014, 11:29:10 PM
He doesn't want to take it separately. It says is we have questions to call a number, but I didn't have time today at work, so I'll try Tuesday. 
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on July 01, 2014, 04:26:42 PM
Bumping for myself.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on July 01, 2014, 06:27:00 PM
Good luck-- but bear in mind, too, that if he is at risk for a medical emergency while testing, this could serve to be a "testing irregularity" for the other students in the room, too.

That's the (additional) reason for individual testing-- because it doesn't place any risk on other testing students.  Irregularities can invalidate an exam.  Unfortunately. With the PSAT, that may outweigh his desire to not be singled out, I'm afraid.  Those and the AP exams are one-time deals-- not like the SAT where you can just take it on the next available date.  KWIM?

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on July 01, 2014, 06:50:34 PM
Good point. 

He ended up liking the individual testing for the ACT.  He finished early overall and got to go to the bathroom when he needed.  :)

I need to start the paperwork for the SAT and the PSAT. The SAT will be first.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on July 02, 2014, 12:46:24 AM
Oddly, DD preferred testing in a group setting!!  When she took the ACT there wasn't time to apply for accommodations, and she wound up doing slightly better on all the sections except writing.  Go figure, right?? 

We just didn't tell anyone, and because they didn't know her at the testing site, it was fine.  Nobody questioned it, and the proctor was fine with her having her meds UNDER her seat, and not in the pile of everyone else's junk at the side of the room.  (We didn't want her epipens there since there was likely nut residue on at least some coats, backpacks, etc.)
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on August 19, 2014, 09:33:14 PM
bump
Title: PSAT Accommodations
Post by: maeve on September 03, 2014, 11:17:26 AM
I have to sign DD up for the PSAT ASAP.  I was put in touch with the special ed coordinator at her school through a grade-level special ed teacher who attended her 504 meeting last week. 


What accommodations did those of you whose kids have taken it request? At the very least, I would like a food free room and for the phone and EpiPens to be in the room (even if they're left with the proctor).
Title: Re: PSAT Accommodations
Post by: CMdeux on September 03, 2014, 11:23:23 AM
I know that we have a thread about this-- it's a process, applying for accommodations with College Board.

"Food free room" isn't one of the options, btw-- so don't even try for that one, because it'll just get kicked back to you. You'll have to work that one out with the local administering agency/people at the test site.

The ONLY standard accommodation that they will grant is "clocks stopped breaks as needed" and "meds in room."  NO phone.  DD gave hers to her proctor and I sat outside the room when she took it.

This will mean individual testing-- it's a de facto conclusion since "clocks stopped as needed" is idiosyncratic and individual.
Title: Re: PSAT Accommodations
Post by: maeve on September 03, 2014, 11:26:24 AM
Hmm.  Sitting outside the room could be problematic as the test is being administered during the week at the HS closest to our house. I work so that could be an issue.
Title: Re: PSAT Accommodations
Post by: CMdeux on September 03, 2014, 11:26:37 AM
College Board and accommodations?: has anyone gone through this process?

Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)


If you hunt, there are pretty good guidelines on support boards for seizure disorders and diabetes-- the other conditions for which similar accommodations re: the environment and medical care seem to most closely align.  It's VERY frustrating to not be able to just ask for what is actually necessary, and be stuck asking instead for stuff that shouldn't be needed if you COULD just ask for what matters, if that makes sense.

Title: Re: PSAT Accommodations
Post by: CMdeux on September 03, 2014, 11:28:13 AM
It takes about 3mo to run through the official process with CB.  If she's taking it in October, that ship will have sailed already-- the choices will be:  a) take your chances and do it as-is, b) hope to negotiate 'no-food' with test site personnel on the day, or c) skip it.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on September 03, 2014, 11:48:39 AM
If ANYTHING were ever a CLEAR, CLEAR reason to get a 504 plan in place no matter how well things are covered by school policy, though, this is it.  One of the easiest ways to be denied by the College Board is to have no 504 plan, or one that has been active less than a year.

I just hope that spurs someone to act while their child is still in elementary-- this stuff really matters later on in terms of history of documented accommodations and longevity of official qualification under 504.   :yes:  It will matter in college, too.


Just feel the need to put this one front.and.center again.   :yes:
Title: Re: PSAT Accommodations
Post by: maeve on September 03, 2014, 11:50:20 AM
It takes about 3mo to run through the official process with CB.  If she's taking it in October, that ship will have sailed already-- the choices will be:  a) take your chances and do it as-is, b) hope to negotiate 'no-food' with test site personnel on the day, or c) skip it.

We can't skip it.  DD wants to apply to the local Academy of Science (AOS) or HS, and the PSAT is the entrance exam. I think it's also used for Thomas Jefferson HS of Science (highly ranked STEM HS), which she also wants to apply to. I think she might have a shot at AOS, but TJ would be a serious long shot.  I so wished I'd gone to the info meetings last spring but DD was kind of waffling on whether to apply.
Title: Re: PSAT Accommodations
Post by: Macabre on September 03, 2014, 12:05:16 PM
The deadline for accommodations was last week.

I missed it. Also missed SAT accommodations deadline.

Hmmm. Can we combine threads?  I've listed what DS had for ACT  accommodations in the other thread.

Maeve do they take it two years early at your HS?
Title: Re: PSAT Accommodations
Post by: maeve on September 03, 2014, 12:42:25 PM
McC,
They don't take PSAT 2 years early at our HS.  DD is taking it as part of an admissions process to get into the Academy of Science, which is an alternative HS (really a part-time program in that she'll spend alternating days at this school and at her home HS).  The PSAT is part of the initial screen process.

I'm actually worried she won't do well on the math portion.  She's just starting algebra now.  She did do a PSAT prep course a couple of weeks ago; really an AOS prep course.

It turns out that she'll take the PSAT on Saturday, 18 October. So I could sit outside the classroom, if allowed.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on September 03, 2014, 12:55:01 PM
{I just merged the two threads}
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: maeve on September 03, 2014, 01:26:39 PM
Thanks CM.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Beach Girl on September 03, 2014, 07:42:55 PM
Having been through PSAT several times (took it from middle school up through 11th grade), there is really not a lot to worry about as far as food allergies.  They are very very strict about no eating or even having food out during the test.  I never saw any food during all the times I took PSAT, SAT twice, ACT, SAT subject tests twice, and AP tests.  Phones are allowed in the room, but not on the student.  Same with meds.  I would not get all stressed out over this.  I am severely allergic to peanuts and never saw so much as a crumb of anything during all these tests.  (Also, I would have been absolutely mortified to have my mother sitting outside of the room when I was in middle school and high school.)
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on September 03, 2014, 09:26:38 PM
What's concern in is the possibility of the PSAT being taken in the cafeteria, and it's clear that's been the case for some.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Beach Girl on September 04, 2014, 09:40:30 AM
What's concern in is the possibility of the PSAT being taken in the cafeteria, and it's clear that's been the case for some.

They are required to sit each student at a separate desk, so it would be difficult to find a cafeteria that has individual desks rather than the standard cafeteria tables.  Normally they divide the students into different classrooms in order to comply with the rule about desks. 
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: maeve on September 04, 2014, 11:53:44 AM
What's concern in is the possibility of the PSAT being taken in the cafeteria, and it's clear that's been the case for some.

They are required to sit each student at a separate desk, so it would be difficult to find a cafeteria that has individual desks rather than the standard cafeteria tables.  Normally they divide the students into different classrooms in order to comply with the rule about desks. 

I took my SAT in the cafeteria of my HS, so it has been done.  It was the absolute worst place to take the SAT.  I took the SSAT in an auditorium I think and the PSAT in a classroom.  I took AP and a second SAT in a classroom; though the proctor of the second SAT let kids into the exam late after the break, which is a no no.

So these sorts of variances do happen and have to be planned for.  The exam will be given at a HS in our district that my DD is unfamiliar, will never attend, and at which she is unknown to those administering the test. Such are the vagaries of a large, county-based school district (73,000 students) vs. a town-based district (fewer than 5,000 students) in which I attended.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on September 04, 2014, 12:58:22 PM
DS took the ACT in a school he had only visited for a theatre performance in a self-contained theatre. It wasn't in our district and was 20 miles away. It's one reason I'm glad he had accommodations.

He was in an office, not a classroom. A table, not a desk.

I was in the car and never went in (except for a potty break but saw no kids). 

His PSAT will be in one of our school'a lecture rooms. Again, no desks but a seat at very long tables.

He'll take the SAT at a nearby school. No accommodations.  I didn't get it done. At least he has been in the SAT school for speech tournaments.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on September 04, 2014, 03:54:01 PM
What's concern in is the possibility of the PSAT being taken in the cafeteria, and it's clear that's been the case for some.

They are required to sit each student at a separate desk, so it would be difficult to find a cafeteria that has individual desks rather than the standard cafeteria tables.  Normally they divide the students into different classrooms in order to comply with the rule about desks.

I'm pretty sure that table seating is okay-- DD took both PSAT and SAT that way-- in classrooms without individual desks-- and also the ACT, which had to be MOVED into a computer lab with only table seating.

We hoped for the best with the ACT, and it was fine-- DD was moved and I was outside the room, and the proctor was okay hanging onto her meds and phone, and allowed her to wipe down her seat, and sit on an end of the long tables. 

In all three exams, some students were seated in areas/rooms which are intended for food consumption.  DD just got very lucky with the ACT room assignment. 


Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Beach Girl on September 04, 2014, 08:22:03 PM
Current rules for the official testing are that kids cannot sit at the same table.  So, sure, I guess if your child is taking it alone, it could be in the cafeteria by himself/herself or an office or a computer lab.  But it also requires an area where people are not coming and going, and the cafeteria is high on traffic.  Maeve, the rules may have been different years ago when you were in high school (if you have a child taking it now, then you went to high school 15 - 20 years ago?), but it is a new world now.  Lots of pressure and kids who have no objection to cheating. 

If your concern is that your child will be in the cafeteria testing alone and you are worried about crumbs on the tables, I would suggest just bringing wipes.  Studies have shown that gets rid of the food protein (referring to allergies, not microbes).   You don`t need any special accomodations to bring in a couple of wipes, clean the area, and get rid of the wipes (hand to the proctor or put them in the trash).   I did that for each test I took just to feel more comfortable.   If you are worried about your child being exposed to food from another student, that won`t happen, because no food is allowed to be out.  They are extremely strict about that.

I also took these tests at several different locations (four different schools for all of these tests, two of which I had never been to before), and the rules are the same everywhere.  There can`t be a different standard for different schools.  They take this very seriously (much more so than even final exams in high school).

I also did an SAT prep class, and they said everything I said above.  No eating, no food can be out, you can bring a cell phone into the room, but have to hand it in to an area in the center, two students cannot be seated at the same table, so desks are used, etc.  Same rules thoughout the U.S.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on September 04, 2014, 08:37:03 PM
Carefulmom,  at our school they are not taken at separate desks. Neither was son's AP test. The lecture hall consists of ten rows of tables.  Now, kids are seated far apart from each other. But they are tables.

Food is ubiquitous at our school unfortunately. :/

But DS didn't have trouble during his ap test. He doesn't have trouble going from class to class or sitting at desks in five different classrooms every Saturday at speech tournaments. So I'm not too worried that he needs to wipe things down. Though that was one accommodation for his ACT.

We'll see how it goes. Missing the deadlines for the SAT and the PSAT (he'll take the SAT before the PSAT, lol) were not what  I had planned, but I think will work out.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: maeve on September 05, 2014, 11:28:46 AM
OK, I received word this morning from the Spec. Ed contact at DD's school that we can still apply for accommodations from the College Board. She is requesting individual testing.  I think I should also ask that her meds and phone be kept with the proctor; I'd even suggest that we can put them in a Ziploc so that it's obvious that nothing else was brought in.

I need to contact the director of the school she's applying to, which will be administering the test, to see what accommodations they can grant. 

Any other suggestions?
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: maeve on September 05, 2014, 11:36:32 AM
Beach Girl,
Yes I did take the exams eons ago but the impetus to cheat was not less then, certainly not among the students I went to school with (who routinely cheated off me, were in the National Honor Society, and a few went on to service academies). Intense academic pressure existed then especially among highly competitive schools/classes. Difference in class rank in my class was a matter of hundreths of a point, much as it is now.

Also, being a bit older and in the world for a while has shown me that rules may be rules, but they are not always applied the same way. With the PSAT (according to the info my POC got from the College Board), there is a fair amount of latitude given to the schools.

I appreciate your input but as CMDeux and McC have also shown, the experience I had 28 years ago happens now.  Therefore, it's best to plan for the imperfect world we live in and make sure accommodations are in place.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on September 05, 2014, 11:58:37 AM
OK, I received word this morning from the Spec. Ed contact at DD's school that we can still apply for accommodations from the College Board. She is requesting individual testing.  I think I should also ask that her meds and phone be kept with the proctor; I'd even suggest that we can put them in a Ziploc so that it's obvious that nothing else was brought in.

I need to contact the director of the school she's applying to, which will be administering the test, to see what accommodations they can grant. 

Any other suggestions?

Honestly, you may have better luck with "clocks-stopped breaks, as needed" rather than "individual testing" per se.

Yes, they amount to the exact same thing-- the student alone with a proctor-- but the latter, they seemed to want a LOT more documentation than we provided them with.  And I basically laid out what we gave college board.  Recall, this also included reaction history and DD's is pretty spectacular w/r/t rapidity and bizarre symptoms from really, really trace amounts.  I'd think that if ANYONE could qualify for "individual" testing, it'd be DD, since that's how her school has always done her state testing-- that is, it was a long-standing provision in her 504 plan, even, and College Board was unconvinced-- after 11 weeks.  (Which I realize you don't have).

I vote for "Clocks stopped breaks, as needed," because that one, they seemed to 'get' the need for (as in, to evaluate symptoms or check on asthma, etc.).



Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Beach Girl on September 10, 2014, 08:32:20 PM
Carefulmom,  at our school they are not taken at separate desks. Neither was son's AP test. The lecture hall consists of ten rows of tables.  Now, kids are seated far apart from each other. But they are tables.

Food is ubiquitous at our school unfortunately. :/

But DS didn't have trouble during his ap test. He doesn't have trouble going from class to class or sitting at desks in five different classrooms every Saturday at speech tournaments. So I'm not too worried that he needs to wipe things down. Though that was one accommodation for his ACT.

We'll see how it goes. Missing the deadlines for the SAT and the PSAT (he'll take the SAT before the PSAT, lol) were not what  I had planned, but I think will work out.

For college board tests, they can get in so much trouble for breaking the rules (sharing a table, having food out).  Food was ubiquitous at my high school as well.  Not for college board testing, though.  Too much to lose if they don`t comply.  I guess if no one knows to report it, then there are no consequences. 

Not sure who "Carefulmom" is....
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: maeve on October 05, 2014, 04:29:08 PM
OK. so College Board had suggested speaking directly with the school. The admissions director took a week to get back to me (and only have I put a deadline with threats to escalate in my second email). She was not accommodating (pun intended), so we had already signed DD up for the PSAT and paid for the test. They will not grant accommodations. Parents are not allowed in the testing site. The other option offered to us was for DD to take the SAT in December as an alternate admission test. This would not be fair because she's just started taking algebra. The SAT would be beyond her capabilities now at age 13.

So can I send her into the test with her inhaler, phone, and EpiPens in a plastic bag and have her hand them to the proctor? The test is next Saturday at 8 am.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on October 05, 2014, 06:41:38 PM
That's what I would do. She has epis not Auvis?  If she she has Auvis I would just have her keep one in her pocket, a cell phone that is turned off  in another pocket and her bag with an inhaler to the proctor. And a wet one packet if she needs to wipe her desk down.

Then you can have epis in the car outside.

Otherwise doing what you suggested and hoping the proctor will take it.


Also, not allowing the parents at a testing site is ludicrous. How would they kick any parent out of a public school?
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on October 05, 2014, 06:44:50 PM
Frankly DS use to keep two epis in pants pockets. If she could find keeping one of them and a phone in pockets comfortable, she could have control in case she needed them.

What ticks me off is that she could have added anxiety about this (I hope not).

We are going into both SAT and PSAT without accommodations, but dS is not feeling anxiety. During the PSAT the school nurse will be there. Probably not during the SAT, though.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: CMdeux on October 05, 2014, 07:32:57 PM
That is what DD did for the ACT, incidentally-- I stayed just outside the testing room, and just sat there with my knitting the entire 4h.  The proctor knew I was there.

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: SkyScorcher on October 06, 2014, 12:40:05 AM
Frankly DS use to keep two epis in pants pockets. If she could find keeping one of them and a phone in pockets comfortable, she could have control in case she needed them.

I only have two pairs of pants that can fit anything larger than a small smartphone in them.... and that's because I buy boys' cargo pants.  Girls' pants don't have pockets anymore.   :tongue:
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: ajasfolks2 on October 06, 2014, 09:29:51 AM
It sounds to me like there needs to be a concerted effort to get the Nat'l org to get it WRT anaphylaxis and LTFA accommodations during testing.

I know this is not helpful in the immediate for maeve's situation . . .

There needs to be some change on national level here . . .

(I know, in our copious free time, right?!)

Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: Macabre on October 06, 2014, 09:47:38 AM
Well, there is a process for getting accommodations. But Maeve wasn't given enough notice to go through it, and I sid not have the time.

Really, DS is without someone to administer other than him (or friends who can work the Auvi) a lot.  In a way, for us, this won't be very different. DS is older, as are  most kids who will be taking these tests. They are off by themselves and with friends a lot.

Maeve's situation is unique in that her dd is having to take it at a  younger age for something unrelated to what they are normally used for. And of course Sky was also quite young when she took the PSAT.


But I don't know how this set up would be practically difderent for DS than sitting in classrooms during a speech round. He has at least five of those every Saturday at a different high school each week.

DS appreciated having accommodations for the ACT, but he's not worried about not having them for the SAT or PSAT--both of which will be at a differrnt school I relaized this morning.

Yea, the College Board needs to get on board, lol. But there is a means of getting accommodation. If they were more like the ACT protocol for getting them, DS would have them.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: PurpleCat on October 06, 2014, 03:13:16 PM
DD is taking PSAT next weekend.  She is one year early to take it.  I contacted the guidance dept. at the school where the test is being given.  She is allowed to bring her purse with her meds and phone but the phone must be turned off.  All proctors are faculty who are trained to give epinephrine.  When she is assigned an actual classroom, that proctor will be alerted to her needs.

I could not have asked for more.

Our first experience is a good one.
Title: Re: Seeking official accommodations via the College Board (SAT/PSAT/AP)
Post by: maeve on October 21, 2014, 11:34:05 PM
DD took the PSAT on Saturday (with tons of other 8th graders hoping to get into this STEM program). We put her EpiPens, inhaler, and phone in a Ziploc bag labeled with her name. She handed it to the proctor when she arrived, and the proctor quipped something along the lines of "hope we don't make you have to use these." I think it was likely in jest. All went well.  We'll find out scores in December and in January will find out if she makes it to the next round.

She thought the test was easy. Regardless of the outcome, this was good practice for the PSAT, SAT, etc. when they really count.  Our application for accommodations with the College Board is still being processed. The staff member, who's shepherding it for us said that once in place, that they'll be in place until a year after high school graduation; so there'll be no need to go through the process again in the future.

Thanks for the guidance, help, and support.