Food Allergy Support

Discussion Boards => Main Discussion Board => Topic started by: Arkadia on February 02, 2012, 08:32:04 AM

FAS has upgraded our forum security. Some members may need to log in again. If you are unable to remember your login information, please email food.allergy.supt@flash.net and we will help you get back in. Thanks for your patience!

Title: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 02, 2012, 08:32:04 AM
http://www.foodallergy.org/page/last-minute-reminders-for-valentines-day-classroom-parties

Quote
•Call the room parent or teacher (whoever is taking the lead on organizing the party) to remind them about your child’s food allergies and discuss how your child can participate in the event equally alongside his/her classmates. 
•Reinforce safety rules with your child about not accepting foods that have not been cleared by you or another designated adult.
•Remind your child not to open any Valentine’s Day candies from classmates.
•If it’s not too late, suggest some games and easy crafts that can be done during the party in lieu of eating food in the classroom.
•Work out a plan with your child’s teacher to have students wash their hands and/or use wipes after handling food. Send in extra wipes for the teacher to have on hand for students to use if they eat foods that contain your child’s allergen.


Enabler much?
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 02, 2012, 08:39:55 AM
Code: [Select]
Call the room parent

oh, f***. I was at a planning meeting this week, I don't have a food allergic child in the class, and the uncomfortable silence I got suggesting that maybe "strawberry flavored" sodas being used (sugar anyone?wellness policies?a child with RED FOOD DYE ALLERGIES) in the class (and peanut allergic) might not be a good idea was proof enough talking to "room parents" is a lost cause.

I've been down that road before, with my older son and his allergies, and the principal was present, and I GOT SQUAT. Save for the eye rolls.

I did ask however what would become of candies and um....bakery style trays of cupcakes delivered on valentines day by parents not involved in party planning.

I had to fish it out, but managed to reel in a "they will be sent home".  I'll try to clarify if that means in backpacks.  ~)
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 02, 2012, 08:51:40 AM
Code: [Select]
Reinforce safety rules with your child

fine, but it's the adults I generally find need reinforcing. At at young ages, recent deaths (Virginia girl) show this is not foolproof. My son almost died in kinder as a result of another child lying to him about the ingredients and pressuring him into eating a "cheese cracker" that was actually a peanut butter flavored keebler. In younger grades there needs to be some oversight, or broad education. For everyone in a classroom with children at risk.

No quoting:  at that meeting this week I tried to reinforce the idea that the classroom had milk, peanut, and red dye food allergies, and that maybe a food free party was in order, but egads.....it won't be valentines day without punch and hot chocolate.  :misspeak: I was assigned prizes, because of course, I'm the only parent in the group with a child with food allergies. I'm getting a few COOL!! prizes for the food allergic children, FOR SURE.

I have this creepy feeling PINK HOT CHOCOLATE is going to show up valentines day. Yup. It exists. Because you know, it would exclude those with peanut, red dye, and milk allergies in one fell swoop.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 02, 2012, 09:30:26 AM
Code: [Select]
If it’s not too late,
editor miss a deadline, or is this really that last minute afterthought CYA?
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: maeve on February 02, 2012, 11:47:59 AM
Code: [Select]
Call the room parent

oh, f***. I was at a planning meeting this week, I don't have a food allergic child in the class, and the uncomfortable silence I got suggesting that maybe "strawberry flavored" sodas being used (sugar anyone?wellness policies?a child with RED FOOD DYE ALLERGIES) in the class (and peanut allergic) might not be a good idea was proof enough talking to "room parents" is a lost cause.

I've been down that road before, with my older son and his allergies, and the principal was present, and I GOT SQUAT. Save for the eye rolls.

I did ask however what would become of candies and um....bakery style trays of cupcakes delivered on valentines day by parents not involved in party planning.

I had to fish it out, but managed to reel in a "they will be sent home".  I'll try to clarify if that means in backpacks.  ~)

I think the main issue I have with that is that they are suggesting that you forgo  your child's right to medical privacy for the sake of a) a class party and b) making it easier for the teacher and other parents.  I, unfortunately, made that mistake early in my child's educational career and it haunts you in so many ways.  It's a shame that FAAN isn't up to snuff on the civil rights and privacy laws protecting school age children.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Mfamom on February 02, 2012, 12:27:16 PM
yes and I hate it when the protocol becomes call the allergic kid's parents and check with them.  That's where things seem to go south. 
Then, it becomes the parents of kids with allergies being the bad guy plus seeming to be "in charge".

They should handle this from nurse to parents or nurse to teacher to parents. 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 02, 2012, 01:07:46 PM
yes and I hate it when the protocol becomes call the allergic kid's parents and check with them.  That's where things seem to go south. 
Then, it becomes the parents of kids with allergies being the bad guy plus seeming to be "in charge".

They should handle this from nurse to parents or nurse to teacher to parents.

Oh I still remember with unrestrained glee you flinging those errant homemade brownies into the Gar-Bage.

I plan on keeping that move in my back pocket. WHOOSH. Gone.

"MFAmom Maneuver"
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Janelle205 on February 02, 2012, 01:15:32 PM
yes and I hate it when the protocol becomes call the allergic kid's parents and check with them.  That's where things seem to go south. 
Then, it becomes the parents of kids with allergies being the bad guy plus seeming to be "in charge".

They should handle this from nurse to parents or nurse to teacher to parents. 

Agreed - if the school wants to allow a food fest, then they need to do the legwork - not pass it off on someone else.

I'm so glad that the daycare that I work at tells parents what they need to avoid for our rare treat days.  Even though we don't allow apple items, the director has never told a parent to come ask me what to get - though she has asked me to recommend a brand to her so that she could pass it along to a parent. 


That being said, I am lucky in that the few parents that do know that I'm the allergic one have been extremely kind and accommodating to me.  The kids are as well - one told his mom that they had to get the right kind of popsicles because otherwise I would get sick and have to give myself a shot.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 02, 2012, 01:37:08 PM
Mind-boggling.


For all of the above reasons and probably more.   :disappointed:

"It just wouldn't be {fill-in-the-occasion} without...."

without WHAT, exactly?

the need for grief counselors or litigation in the aftermath??

extensive counseling for children to mitigate psychological damage??

Or is it just about the exclusion, embarrassment, and ALIENATION in the moment?


My personal favorite may just be the half-a$$ed statement:

Quote
If it’s not too late, suggest some games and easy crafts that can be done during the party in lieu of eating food in the classroom.

You know, but only if it's "not too late."  Yeah, if they've already planned out how to endanger your child without bothering to consult you, best to just let it go...  and heaven forbid that you do more than offer any friendly "suggestions" for alternatives.  Don't be bossy.  Be NICE.  Above all, let other people do exactly as they please, even if it means extreme risk or fear for your child and even if it means that you have to do economically crippling things to accomodate them.  Yup... if the other classroom parents want to do things that way, why... why aren't you just THERE for the day?  What?  All day, every day?  Of course... if you really cared about your kid and didn't just want everyone else to take on your :problems: for you (oh BARF)... you'd just quit your job so that you could take care of your own responsibilities... other parents can do as they damned well please without giving it another thought.  Yes, loving and responsible parents, apparently, must.... um.... be the ones homeschooling their children so that nobody else has to interact with them in the first place...  since asking schools to please, just... not do stuff that is LIKELY to result in death or permanent injury... yeah, apparently parents are supposed to act as 24/7 watchdogs for this sort of thing.  By being present all the time, evidently, ready to simply remove our kids if the risk is too high.

  Just in case someone else gets a wild hair to do something that anyone with the IQ of a grapefruit could see was collossally stupid and likely to end in disaster?? 


AUGHHHHHHHH....  But really, that is the subtext with that statement.

SERIOUSLY??

 :rant: :dunce: :paddle:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: YouKnowWho on February 02, 2012, 06:14:27 PM
But haven't you heard?  Teachers have no control over the roommom's - it is entirely up to two randomly picked (achoo bs) "ladies" to be in charge.   And really, if it is a financial hardship to you to pay your part for the class party AND provide safe treats, then maybe your child should sit out.  And then there is the whole well we know your child has allergies but they are so good about them, they don't mind sitting out.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: lakeswimr on February 02, 2012, 07:25:08 PM
There is not supposed to be any food for VD this year and the teacher said she would send home a note telling people to not send candy in cards.  I am still practicing with DS what to do in case food does get sent in and served and in case he gets cards with candy, especially candy that he thinks is safe.  (He is not to eat any of it until he brings it home and we check the label together.)  I think practicing this is very important.  Last party I attended the other FA child was eating candy when I walked in.  DS had the same candy in his bag.  Teacher had passed it out without checking with me.  Thankfully it was allergy-free for both FA kids but it shows that teaching DS not to eat it no matter what is very important because mistakes happen.  Yes, I talked with the teacher about this *in depth* twice. 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: lakeswimr on February 02, 2012, 07:28:27 PM
Bossy or nice hasn't made much difference with the small group who are so into baking at my son's school. They just want what they want and it has nothing to do with me, my son, my son's safety, how nicely or assertively I talk with them or even if they like me or even if they are my friend.  They like those cupcakes so very much it is mind boggling.  At least once a year since DS started school I have felt like my head would explode over this!  I have tried to see things from their point of view but I just can't.  One friend I spoke with and told that it feels they think that a cupcake is more important than DS's life said, it isn't that.  It is that their image of what they want for their child is more important than my child to them.  They aren't thinking about life or death.  So, maybe it isn't *as* selfish as it seems.  I don't know.  I can only hope that I would not be acting that way if roles were reversed.  I'm very sorry, Ark. 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: lakeswimr on February 02, 2012, 07:33:51 PM
I am realizing that there are a lot of people who think that if we don't have a certain food at a party that it isn't a party.  Once year it was ranch dressing (no safe ranch dressing for dairy-allergic kids).  She was so insistent on it.  I didn't really get it.  It was that her child was taught you have to eat a healthy food at parties and the only veggies she would eat would only get eaten with ranch dressing--therefore we HAD to have ranch dressing.  another year it was cheese puffs--HAD to have them.  This year the other parent wanted cheese and salami.  The teacher wanted specific things.  We had friends who wanted dip for chips on new years at our house.  I said, "thank you but we have the food covered."  I put out a huge spread and they seemed happy but they would have REALLY liked that dip to be there.  It really means something to them.  I can kind of see it.  Hanukkah without latkes.  Thanksgiving with pizza instead of traditional foods.  I can see that.  But I can't see it fully enough to get the cupcake mothers. 

Mind-boggling.


For all of the above reasons and probably more.   :disappointed:

"It just wouldn't be {fill-in-the-occasion} without...."

without WHAT, exactly?

the need for grief counselors or litigation in the aftermath??

extensive counseling for children to mitigate psychological damage??

Or is it just about the exclusion, embarrassment, and ALIENATION in the moment?


My personal favorite may just be the half-a$$ed statement:

Quote
If it’s not too late, suggest some games and easy crafts that can be done during the party in lieu of eating food in the classroom.

You know, but only if it's "not too late."  Yeah, if they've already planned out how to endanger your child without bothering to consult you, best to just let it go...  and heaven forbid that you do more than offer any friendly "suggestions" for alternatives.  Don't be bossy.  Be NICE.  Above all, let other people do exactly as they please, even if it means extreme risk or fear for your child and even if it means that you have to do economically crippling things to accomodate them.  Yup... if the other classroom parents want to do things that way, why... why aren't you just THERE for the day?  What?  All day, every day?  Of course... if you really cared about your kid and didn't just want everyone else to take on your :problems: for you (oh BARF)... you'd just quit your job so that you could take care of your own responsibilities... other parents can do as they damned well please without giving it another thought.  Yes, loving and responsible parents, apparently, must.... um.... be the ones homeschooling their children so that nobody else has to interact with them in the first place...  since asking schools to please, just... not do stuff that is LIKELY to result in death or permanent injury... yeah, apparently parents are supposed to act as 24/7 watchdogs for this sort of thing.  By being present all the time, evidently, ready to simply remove our kids if the risk is too high.

  Just in case someone else gets a wild hair to do something that anyone with the IQ of a grapefruit could see was collossally stupid and likely to end in disaster?? 


AUGHHHHHHHH....  But really, that is the subtext with that statement.

SERIOUSLY??

 :rant: :dunce: :paddle:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 02, 2012, 07:58:37 PM
Bossy or nice hasn't made much difference with the small group who are so into baking at my son's school. They just want what they want and it has nothing to do with me, my son, my son's safety, how nicely or assertively I talk with them or even if they like me or even if they are my friend.  They like those cupcakes so very much it is mind boggling.  At least once a year since DS started school I have felt like my head would explode over this!  I have tried to see things from their point of view but I just can't.  One friend I spoke with and told that it feels they think that a cupcake is more important than DS's life said, it isn't that. It is that their image of what they want for their child is more important than my child to them.  They aren't thinking about life or death.  So, maybe it isn't *as* selfish as it seems.  I don't know.  I can only hope that I would not be acting that way if roles were reversed.  I'm very sorry, Ark.

I really do think this is accurate.  It's just that when you isolate that particular statement, add in the fact that this often isn't even about "inclusion" so much as choices that pose a real and unacceptably high risk of death or serious injury to our children...

well, I hope that this is because they "don't get" what "life-threatening food allergy" means.  I am not sure how that is even possible in some cases I can readily bring to mind, since they make all the right noises during "education" on the subject... I suppose that they are simply tuning it all out in favor of what they (ignorantly, mostly) "already know" about it.  But I digress.

  If they DO really understand, then that pretty much takes the cake in terms of selfish statements, when you think about it...

I wasn't thinking about YOUR child with the known seizure disorder.  I was just thinking about how much fun it would be for my child to play with the laser strobe light during show-and-tell.

What classroom DOESN'T look forward to a surprise visit from a whole litter of KITTENS??  I never thought about your child's cat allergy and asthma, even though the teacher sent home reminders about no pets.

I just thought it would be fun for my child to build a skateboard run on the wheelchair ramp.  I wasn't thinking about your child at all.


Okay, just to clarify, I cannot BEGIN to wrap my head around "fun" for my own kid trumping concern for not causing physical pain, distress, humiliation or actual harm to another person's child at the same time.  Can't go there.  (Which is, I think, what Lakeswimr was also saying.)  :disappointed:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: eggallergymom on February 02, 2012, 08:17:23 PM
Bossy or nice hasn't made much difference with the small group who are so into baking at my son's school. They just want what they want and it has nothing to do with me, my son, my son's safety, how nicely or assertively I talk with them or even if they like me or even if they are my friend.  They like those cupcakes so very much it is mind boggling.  At least once a year since DS started school I have felt like my head would explode over this!  I have tried to see things from their point of view but I just can't.  One friend I spoke with and told that it feels they think that a cupcake is more important than DS's life said, it isn't that.  It is that their image of what they want for their child is more important than my child to them.  They aren't thinking about life or death.  So, maybe it isn't *as* selfish as it seems.  I don't know.  I can only hope that I would not be acting that way if roles were reversed.  I'm very sorry, Ark.

This has been our experience as well. Our school principal has already sent home a letter warning parents that any candy or baked goods sent in for the Valentine's Day party will not be distributed, but they'll send them in anyway. I can guarantee that there will be kids bringing in valentines with lollipops or candy hearts attached, and they'll "get by" the teachers. My DD's teacher has done a good job running interference with the parents in her room. She told me that a mom was livid at the winter holiday party because the teacher refused to distribute goody bags that included candy canes to the kids. This woman argued and argued with the teacher that "candy canes aren't food!!" Really? So what do YOU do with a candy cane?  ~)  I'd like to believe these people are just ignorant--that they don't know that my daughter could die if she eats the wrong food--but I just don't think they care. It's horrible that I've reached that conclusion, but the last year has been, ahem, enlightening.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: maeve on February 02, 2012, 09:05:15 PM
Really? So what do YOU do with a candy cane? 

Well it could make a very minty suppository. ;)
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Mfamom on February 02, 2012, 09:10:11 PM
But haven't you heard?  Teachers have no control over the roommom's - it is entirely up to two randomly picked (achoo bs) "ladies" to be in charge.   And really, if it is a financial hardship to you to pay your part for the class party AND provide safe treats, then maybe your child should sit out.  And then there is the whole well we know your child has allergies but they are so good about them, they don't mind sitting out.

what I did like about our elem. school is that the room mom did not have carte blanche to do whatever she wanted.  The parties schoolwide had to be similar.  There were generally 3 classes for each grade.  the day of the room mom/teacher meeting, they told the moms EXACTLY what to do.  This kept things sane and kept people from one upping each other which is why the rule was put in place. 

Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Mfamom on February 02, 2012, 09:12:13 PM
lol Arkadia, glad I blazed an image in your mind.  It was actually Peanut brittle at Family card night.  :)
Maybe brownies with nuts on top.  Fuzzy now, but I know it was something outwardly nutty. 

Hell yeah, I'd do it again in a heartbeat.  Liberating.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 02, 2012, 09:56:23 PM
I have a grinchy smile a MILE wide every time I remember that, Mfamom.  I think it was nut-topped brownies.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 06, 2012, 02:18:20 PM
No quoting:  oh f***. email from room mom telling us "the snack" provided by school organization for v-day is ICECREAM. Yeah, in a room with milk allergies and the question is do we change the drink from something citrusy to something more compatable with icecream.  Yeah...

um. sure. wouldn't want someone vomitting ice cream all over the milk allergic children.  :misspeak:

I've got an idea?  How about an extra bag of v-day yo yos and party rings, and one more game and just nix the food?

should I even reply feeling as snarky as I am?
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: YouKnowWho on February 06, 2012, 02:27:54 PM
Ask which one is going to pony up for the epi-pen and which one will pay for the counseling for the emotional traumatization of the child :)

Yeah, I am way beyond snarky today.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Janelle205 on February 06, 2012, 02:59:20 PM
You know, I got out of the preschool room before anything 'really' bad started happening with my last reaction...but still, those kids were worried, and they were scared.

Why would anyone want to chance having to have their child see that?

I can still remember the kids looking at me with really big eyes while I was turning red, coughing, and trying to breathe.  "Miss Janelle, you need to go to the doctor." Miss Janelle, you need to get some of that cough medicine." "Miss Janelle, you need to take a deep breath.  You don't look good."  "Miss Janelle, are you sick?"  They were scared, and that was before it even got really bad.



My sister passed away when she was in preschool.  She died at home, not at school.  Even at that age, her death had such a profound effect on one of her classmates that the same girl (she was on my hs softball team with me, 2 years behind in school) regularly visited her grave site through high school, and wrote letters that she left there.  It had that much of an effect on her.  I cannot even imagine how watching one of their classmates and friends die would affect an elementary student.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 07, 2012, 10:06:19 AM
 i shouldnt send emails when im on my stairmachine..... :misspeak:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 07, 2012, 11:01:41 AM
OH my.  With a teaser like that you at least have to give a few hints, Ark.   ;D
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 07, 2012, 12:23:41 PM
I will once im sure shes not going to stalk me online...
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 07, 2012, 09:44:58 PM
The patently infantile response I get from people wrt accommodating a child with food allergies to this day stuns me.

No quoting:
 This woman is a teacher. I cc'd "reply all" to the other two mothers just to keep things honest, and in an attempt to deflect the claws I sensed lurking beneath the fluffy facade.

I gave myself TWO days to contemplate a response. One line for each day.  :)  i was ever so ginger. Cautious. Eggshells.  in response to a group email notifying us icecream would be served (by an organization that deals out food for such events at the school) and inquiring as to what substitute for the citrus beverage might be a better choice (but ignoring the OBVIOUS that icecream probably isn't a good idea in the presence of not only a milk allergy, but a peanut allergy) Classroom has milk, red dye, and peanut allergies. No mention of the peanut allergy so far.

No quoting at all, this is going to get deleted.

In order of transcription:

"Ok...ice cream will be offered as the snack and a lemon bar to the child who has allergies, should we change the drink from lemonade to something that would go better with ice cream?
 Caprisun, Mott's 100% Apple juice, Tropicana
Orange Juice
...I can look and buy a differnt more ice cream friendly juice w/out dye!
let me know your thoughts"



My reply:

"Whatever works water is good too. Inclusion is a wonderful valentine theme.

How are we going to navigate the milk allergy with the messy kindergardeners? "

In 36 pt font she replied to me:

The child with the milk allergy will have an lemon ice bar and a parent will be bringing in Capri Sun's for all of the children as they do not have any dyes or added coloring. See you on Tuesday

end no quote.  



The font says it all. I better get the hell out of her way.  Or....I could just ask about the peanut allergy next and ask how to turn off the accessibility function on my laptop....sending it to the other two mothers involved for full disclosure. Egads. Maybe the teacher too, but not expecting any sympathy there.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: maeve on February 07, 2012, 09:50:32 PM
People can be so obtuse.  Been there done that with ice cream and gummi bears in a kindergarten class.  Ice cream had egg and was cross-contaminated with nuts and the gummi bears were Black Forest, which have peanut oil.  The best thing about the whole situation:  The room mom who planned the food had children with the same allergies as my DD (egg, peanut) and is a nurse.  So even people who are "managing" food allergies daily don't get it and how even if my DD had her own ice cream and gummis that ice cream smeared all over the tables by 5 and 6 year olds would be dangerous for a contact-reactive child.

Unfortunately, that agressive, party-planning mom you're dealing with may never get it. 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 07, 2012, 10:25:44 PM
Yeah, but this is the teacher...


I mean, WTF.... 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 07, 2012, 10:41:01 PM
Yeah, but this is the teacher...


I mean, WTF....

shes just a mom who happens to be a teacher. not *the* teacher.  elementary i think different school district.

do you think the milk allergy is her child?  trying to figure out in a room with multiple allergies what her qualification to be planning the party is?

recently, i heard the peanut allergic child switched their sticker on treat day and got a treat they werent supposed to get. ( stickers indicate treat or no treat ). Child apparently sobbed when they took it away.  (they ate some). i could buy a few packs of squinkies to give the allergic kids....
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: maeve on February 07, 2012, 11:30:57 PM
Ark, I think you're sweet for trying to make it up to the FA kids with squinkies.  My experience is that often the room moms/party planning moms do not have experience with food allergies.  Also, unfortunately from prior experience once you as an FA mom are room mom and push for inclusion (by perhaps not serving food in a class with two kids with MFA) that you will never again be selected to be room mom. 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Momcat on February 07, 2012, 11:34:50 PM
Yeah, if lemon bars are just as good, why isn't everybody having them?  Hm?  :pout:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: maeve on February 07, 2012, 11:35:00 PM
OK...I'm going to put this out there because it's been rattling around in my head since the story about the 7-year-old in Omaha was posted:  I don't think food will be pulled from classrooms until the family of an allergic child who is injured sues the school and party planning moms.  Personally, if my child required expensive medical care and potentially long-term care in a rehab center because of hypoxia caused by a reaction, I would sue all involved for at least the cost of care.  I'm not normally a sue-happy person, but it seems that despite my best due diligence that food that shouldn't be in the classroom shows up.  I honestly don't think that until non-FA families realize that their own pocketbooks could be affected because they had to push for crap food to be served in a class, that things won't change.  They just don't think they have any liability in the situation.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: maeve on February 07, 2012, 11:35:22 PM
Yeah, if lemon bars are just as good, why isn't everybody having them?  Hm?  :pout:

Exactly! 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 07, 2012, 11:37:05 PM
I happen to agree with you, Maeve.

It's sad that not even the actual death of children gets through to these over-entitled under-occupied parents that promote the junk-food festival inside classrooms, (after all, those are someone else's kids and they don't even know them, so why on earth should it matter), but I think you're right.  After all, it isn't their kids who are at risk; it's OURS.

That's some kind of selfish, all right.  But it's really and truly the only logical explanation I can come up with that doesn't stretch the bounds of credibility beyond the breaking point.   :-[

Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: maeve on February 07, 2012, 11:40:26 PM
I happen to agree with you, Maeve.

It's sad that not even the actual death of children gets through to these over-entitled under-occupied parents that promote the junk-food festival inside classrooms, (after all, those are someone else's kids and they don't even know them, so why on earth should it matter), but I think you're right.  After all, it isn't their kids who are at risk; it's OURS.

That's some kind of selfish, all right.  But it's really and truly the only logical explanation I can come up with that doesn't stretch the bounds of credibility beyond the breaking point.   :-[



I couldn't agree with you more.  I'm more than positive that if the shoe were on the other foot with these parents that they would be screaming bloody murder for the same accommodations that we fight for.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 06:08:00 AM
I have an IEP meeting today for my daughter. (this class)

The teacher of the class (not room mom). has a highchool age son with a  peanut allergy. (requires epi) my head is swimming.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 06:09:58 AM
Yeah, if lemon bars are just as good, why isn't everybody having them?  Hm?  :pout:

its probably some old lemon bar from treat day found in the freezer.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 06:40:35 AM
OK...I'm going to put this out there because it's been rattling around in my head since the story about the 7-year-old in Omaha was posted:  I don't think food will be pulled from classrooms until the family of an allergic child who is injured sues the school and party planning moms.  Personally, if my child required expensive medical care and potentially long-term care in a rehab center because of hypoxia caused by a reaction, I would sue all involved for at least the cost of care.  I'm not normally a sue-happy person, but it seems that despite my best due diligence that food that shouldn't be in the classroom shows up.  I honestly don't think that until non-FA families realize that their own pocketbooks could be affected because they had to push for crap food to be served in a class, that things won't change.  They just don't think they have ;) any liability in the situation.


Im the mom slash nurse at the party. ;)

how do you think that makes me feel?
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 07:18:38 AM
But no....truly (i was jazzing you maeve, you didnt make me feel bad) my motivation is inclusion.  as a playdate mom ive always been a bit on the obsessive side people are made to feel welcome and treated with special consideration.  my father taught me it was a personal humiliation to be inhospitable or cause a guest distress.  call it a Greek. overly friendly thing. Im sick over this party.   

im embarrased for the party mom.its shameful. 

yes to maeve on once theyve gotten a taste of an inclusive fa party room  mom.  im pretty much box office poison and while i was pleasantly surprised my request to volunteer was finally taken to task cant for the life of me figure out how i slipped past the powers that be.  im going to run the party plans past the school
Nurse just so she is aware of the risk on her shift.  ill tell her in person today and remind her eith an email " paper trail". 

Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 07:20:54 AM
Oh crap. im the party mom slash nurse slash mom of a fa child, huh?
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 09:12:43 AM
I happen to agree with you, Maeve.

It's sad that not even the actual death of children gets through to these over-entitled under-occupied parents that promote the junk-food festival inside classrooms, (after all, those are someone else's kids and they don't even know them, so why on earth should it matter), but I think you're right.  After all, it isn't their kids who are at risk; it's OURS.

That's some kind of selfish, all right.  But it's really and truly the only logical explanation I can come up with that doesn't stretch the bounds of credibility beyond the breaking point.   :-[



I couldn't agree with you more.  I'm more than positive that if the shoe were on the other foot with these parents that they would be screaming bloody murder for the same accommodations that we fight for.

No stretching credibility, just some brutal honesty. I know some of the most resistance I've had from people getting accommodations has been from actual parents/teachers of children with special needs, and in particular those who for whatever reasons didn't identify their own child or advocate for them in the same manner. On any number of special needs. I think it's called "sour grapes", and they have an axe to grind.

But that's a character issue. A person in that situation doesn't always respond in that manner. It can work the other way. It can make them more proactive, maybe even a bit of a zealot, but like I said, it's an extension of someone's CORE. Who they really are.

I will tread accordingly and keep them a safe distance positioning people with the actually ability to change the circumstances based on what is now School Policy between them and myself.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: socks on a rooster on February 08, 2012, 09:54:19 AM
Check out the FAAN "reminders" again. They have changed the first one regarding disclosing to the room mom.  :yes:  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 10:05:42 AM
I happen to agree with you, Maeve.

It's sad that not even the actual death of children gets through to these over-entitled under-occupied parents that promote the junk-food festival inside classrooms, (after all, those are someone else's kids and they don't even know them, so why on earth should it matter), but I think you're right.  After all, it isn't their kids who are at risk; it's OURS.


so what if thr child is "OURS"?  how abour when they do routinely put their child at risk or allow  and be party to exclusion?  what do we chalk that up to?what if that is their school of hard knocks method of parenting?  what if thats what they trade as social currency and to maintain their position in the community?  what if their child IS their social currency?
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 10:08:09 AM
Check out the FAAN "reminders" again. They have changed the first one regarding disclosing to the room mom.  :yes:  :thumbsup:

oh amd we havent even tackled half the list yet....excellent.  how about that..
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 10:09:42 AM
So we are excused from dealing with borderline personalities... is that it? lol!
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 08, 2012, 10:13:22 AM
Oh crap. im the party mom slash nurse slash mom of a fa child, huh?

 :thumbsup:

Thanks-- that made me chuckle this morning.

Sorry that this other person is being such a butthead.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 10:16:11 AM
I think FAAN needs to make a formal retraction.  id like it in 36 pt font.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 08, 2012, 10:22:06 AM
:coffee:


<snort>

  Owwwwwwww...  You should have warned me.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 08, 2012, 10:28:00 AM
How does this sound as a reply to yesterday's email?

"Although I'd LOVE to think our support group was instrumental in FAAN's decision to rescind advice instructing parents of food allergic children to deal with other room parents in obtaining accommodations/empathy related to class celebrations, and specifically, Valentine's Day, I am almost certain your highly visible recap was influential.



HUGS and KISSES!



<THAT MOM>"

complete with before and after and links to FAAN's page....
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: lakeswimr on February 08, 2012, 11:43:21 AM
36 font?  You offended *her*?  ???

How about being very upfront and just telling her that you would like not only this party but ALL food events to be safe and fully inclusive for all the children in the classroom.  You do NOT want ice cream to be served because it leaves out the child with milk allergies and the child with peanut allergies.  You would rather all the children have the SAME treat and list a bunch that are allergy-free.  Tell them you would be willing to be the one to provide the treat (if that is the case.)  Why not ask for what you want very bluntly and directly?  I'm not sure that you haven't but reading this thread it doesn't sound like it. 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: maeve on February 08, 2012, 01:43:56 PM
OK...I'm going to put this out there because it's been rattling around in my head since the story about the 7-year-old in Omaha was posted:  I don't think food will be pulled from classrooms until the family of an allergic child who is injured sues the school and party planning moms.  Personally, if my child required expensive medical care and potentially long-term care in a rehab center because of hypoxia caused by a reaction, I would sue all involved for at least the cost of care.  I'm not normally a sue-happy person, but it seems that despite my best due diligence that food that shouldn't be in the classroom shows up.  I honestly don't think that until non-FA families realize that their own pocketbooks could be affected because they had to push for crap food to be served in a class, that things won't change.  They just don't think they have ;) any liability in the situation.


Im the mom slash nurse at the party. ;)

how do you think that makes me feel?
But no....truly (i was jazzing you maeve, you didnt make me feel bad) my motivation is inclusion.  as a playdate mom ive always been a bit on the obsessive side people are made to feel welcome and treated with special consideration.  my father taught me it was a personal humiliation to be inhospitable or cause a guest distress.  call it a Greek. overly friendly thing. Im sick over this party.   

im embarrased for the party mom.its shameful. 

yes to maeve on once theyve gotten a taste of an inclusive fa party room  mom.  im pretty much box office poison and while i was pleasantly surprised my request to volunteer was finally taken to task cant for the life of me figure out how i slipped past the powers that be.  im going to run the party plans past the school
Nurse just so she is aware of the risk on her shift.  ill tell her in person today and remind her eith an email " paper trail". 



I just saw this now.  I knew your were kidding when I read your last post.  I also didn't want to insinuate anything with the nurse post.  I guess I still get a little surprised how individuals with medical training can be more "relaxed" in dealing with food allergies. 

Anyway, good luck with planning this party.  I don't envy you.  I do love how you are doing your best to get inclusion.  Oh, I can completely agree with your statement about being the type of person who ensures playdates, etc. are inclusive and being raised that way.  I was raised the same way.  It's unfortunate that others were not or have turned their backs on those lessons.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: becca on February 08, 2012, 05:35:14 PM
Code: [Select]
Call the room parent

oh, f***. I was at a planning meeting this week, I don't have a food allergic child in the class, and the uncomfortable silence I got suggesting that maybe "strawberry flavored" sodas being used (sugar anyone?wellness policies?a child with RED FOOD DYE ALLERGIES) in the class (and peanut allergic) might not be a good idea was proof enough talking to "room parents" is a lost cause.

I've been down that road before, with my older son and his allergies, and the principal was present, and I GOT SQUAT. Save for the eye rolls.

I did ask however what would become of candies and um....bakery style trays of cupcakes delivered on valentines day by parents not involved in party planning.

I had to fish it out, but managed to reel in a "they will be sent home".  I'll try to clarify if that means in backpacks.  ~)

I think the main issue I have with that is that they are suggesting that you forgo  your child's right to medical privacy for the sake of a) a class party and b) making it easier for the teacher and other parents.  I, unfortunately, made that mistake early in my child's educational career and it haunts you in so many ways.  It's a shame that FAAN isn't up to snuff on the civil rights and privacy laws protecting school age children.

This. 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: becca on February 08, 2012, 05:36:38 PM
yes and I hate it when the protocol becomes call the allergic kid's parents and check with them.  That's where things seem to go south. 
Then, it becomes the parents of kids with allergies being the bad guy plus seeming to be "in charge".

They should handle this from nurse to parents or nurse to teacher to parents. 

And this!
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: ajasfolks2 on February 08, 2012, 07:10:10 PM


REFUSE TO ENABLE THE FOOD USE!!

FORCE THEM TO DO ALTERNATIVE NONFOOD EVENT . . .

THEY WILL FLINCH.  WE NEED TO STOP FLINCHING!!

Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: rainbow on February 09, 2012, 03:33:08 PM
I'm glad FAAN changed that about the suggestion to contact the class moms. Often, that doesn't go well because these Cupcake Queens want to have what THEY want (baked goods) which are unsafe for children with food allergies.  And they will steamroll that agenda, e.g., "Valentine Cookies are fine for your allergic child, riiiigghttt?  They are going to be sooooo cute!" (with fake smile and doesn't want response other than affirmative from allergy parent).  Or, "Well, YOU are bringing something else for your allergic kid (so we can do anything we want), righhhht?"  Or, "We are sooooo excited about playing Bingo with M&M's!!!"  Then if allergy parent says "Actually, M&M's aren''t safe for peanut allergy" - - response is something like, "But so-and-so with PA eats them!"  or "Ohhhh well I don't know whhhhhaattt we could do then!...."  Then you go to the teacher, explain risks, changes are implemented (sometimes, that's IF you have a teacher that gets it and IF you've negotiated a 504 Plan (and most allergy parents don't have one!!)  -- and the Class Moms don't talk to you for the rest of the year (and nor do their friends and other PTO moms!!).  And, they proceed to isolate you for the rest of elementary school.  All for wanting safe snacks.  The kids don't care (young kids are happy with any snack!), it's the PTO MOMS!!!!!!   :nocupcakes:
[Note: MOST allergic children just eat the baked goods because their parent is in denial and/or they don't want to make any waves with PTO or staff].


Does FAAN read here -- (or did someone write to them)?  Are you listening? -- Because that's how those conversations usually go -- and they isolate the allergy parent/child.  SCHOOL STAFF needs to be more proactive in setting guidlelines for food and/or eliminating/minimizing food.  Did you hear about the 7yo that took a bite of the wrong food during a party (Omaha), was in a coma and life saved with ECMO (lung bypass) machine -- which most hospitals don't even have?!!!

I wish FAAN would be more assertive and explain the RISK of cross contamination and hidden ingredients.  Baked goods are notoriously unsafe.  Reference Dr. Wood's cookie story:

http://drrobertwood.com/myanaphylaxis.shtml

Perhaps FAAN could work with Dr. Wood to share his story on their website or in their recommendations. 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: rainbow on February 09, 2012, 03:49:15 PM
I actually had a mom recently try to tell me that SHE had contacted a friend that works for M&M/Mars (food scientist) to discuss safety of M&M's with them. The M&M employee said they are "safe for peanut allergies" because they "scrub the room" between production runs.  So this mom (who happens to be a Chemist, Phd, very smart) actually tried to argue with me about why I don't let my kid eat M&M's!! 

I just said, "Well they aren't labeling such that they are confident their product is nut-free --- so if they are not confident and have to put a nut warning on their label --  then I'M not confident it is safe, and I'm not going to buy that product or feed it to my severly peanut/treenut allergic child."  Plus, I know M&M's have indeed been XC in past b/c I know there used to be reactions (this was a number of years ago, but how would *i* know they've fixed this problem?!)

This was when dropping my DS off at a small party where they were making sundaes -- and it is one of his best friends -- arrghhh.  I left him only b/c I know she is very smart and would not go against my wishes.  I told her that it is stressful enough managing these situations but when people argue what is safe for MY child, not having to manage a PA/TNA child themselves, it makes it even tougher!  :-/


(will delete later - no quoting please)
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: lakeswimr on February 09, 2012, 05:13:17 PM
You are right, Rainbow--at least as far as my situation goes.  I have had that type of experience with other mothers.  I would LOVE if someone would write an article about this topic that got published in some magazine that was something that those who do not have a child with food allergies could hear and that would convince them to be more compassionate.  I haven't ever seen an article on this topic like that.  I wonder why the other parents can not see our POV or do not care about it.  I *think* I would not act the way I have seen others act.  I am not certain but I *think* I would be the one who wanted to be inclusive to all.  Then again, I"m not super into baking or parties, or food at school and was not even before all this.  What I do know and what I try to remember is that even people I know who are nice people, who are my friends, have a great attachment to food being a certain way at kids' parties.  Those closest to me have changed their pov on this topic thanks to me and DS but most did not start out nearly so understanding.  I don't think being this way means they are such horrible people even though it can certainly feel that way.  Sometimes it is a sign of extreme selfishness but sometimes it is just that they haven't really thought things through yet.  I don't know.  I can't get past wanting to do things that would leave out my child in a way that I know they would not want for their own child.  It is hard to see past that, anyway.  Some people who were most difficult in my life with regard to FAs are now my biggest supporters.  Some are not, though. 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: rainbow on February 09, 2012, 07:41:26 PM
Agree - that would be a great idea for an article.  Maybe Gina Clowes can write one.  Or maybe FAAN can start to research these psychological issues.  Does FAAN realize how difficult the Class Moms can be, and how difficult Principals can be?!!! Or what the 504 process is *really* like?  The principal stonewalling, telling you it's not necessary, delaying, trying to do anything to convince you not to get one, then having to give you one because it's the LAW but making it a difficult process to obtain appropriate (safe and inclusive) accomodations.  All the while knowing the parent is being reasonable and appropriate, but they just don't want anything documented because all they care about is themself in the process.

I remember one conversation in Kindergarten - (my NKA other child's class) - overheard the Class mom talking to the uncomfortable Allergy Mom with a huge bubbly smile saying, "We want to serve cuppppcakkkes at the Halloween party, and we can righhhht? Because last year we had your other DS with the milk allergy and couldn't have annnnyything, so this year it's just your other DS with peanut allergy so we can have cupcakkkaees righhhht?"  The mom just gave her a non answer (she avoids all food prepared by others as her DS#1 has severe anaphylactic milk allergy and DS2 has peanut allergy)...but then talked to the teacher and they agreed on Italian Ice, so teacher must have told Class Mom that was the approved treat.   I was the one that educated this teacher a couple years before (after a very hard K year and finally getting the 504 after K). 

And then at the party, the same Class Mom brought candy for Halloween Bingo without telling anyone. Guess she figured if she didn't ask, she wouldn't have her plans changed!    :P



Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 09, 2012, 08:39:38 PM
That's what they ALL figure out eventually...



And it isn't just "school" either, where they figure it out.  The crap that still shows up even in High School for every possible function or get-together, or work-group is frankly INSANE.  And it doesn't matter if you remind them or not. 

   :disappointed: :rant: :paddle:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 09, 2012, 09:10:02 PM
36 font?  You offended *her*?  ???

How about being very upfront and just telling her that you would like not only this party but ALL food events to be safe and fully inclusive for all the children in the classroom.  You do NOT want ice cream to be served because it leaves out the child with milk allergies and the child with peanut allergies.  You would rather all the children have the SAME treat and list a bunch that are allergy-free.  Tell them you would be willing to be the one to provide the treat (if that is the case.)  Why not ask for what you want very bluntly and directly?  I'm not sure that you haven't but reading this thread it doesn't sound like it.

Oh, I started down that road when we met for over an hour at a restaurant to plan the lousy 45 minute party.  ~) She quickly found out I've navigated teacher jedi mind tricks before. (I'm sure somone had filled her in on who *I* am, too.) Anyways....it just makes me more persistent.

I did discuss it with the teacher  and tattle telled on Room Mom, with the string of emails after my IEP meeting and the teacher's response??:  "Oh, she probably put in in large print so you could read it...I have a hard time reading print that small too..." Uh, this is my 2X3 screen on my PHONE. Most people read their emails on their LAPTOP. She did mention the child with the Red Dye allergy is contact reactive (makes me think of Carmine/colchine(sp?)) I mean, it's highly possible. She said the milk allergy isn't a "bad one".  ??? and something about peanut allergies being so bad (so I'm assuming the peanut allergy is a "bad" one?) Anyways, I only suspect I know who the child is with the peanut/red dye allergy, since no one has given me specifics. I'm not sure who to keep an eye on...

I DID speak with the district sped director at the same meeting, and she just might get the "food free" ball rolling (or reinforced). It's all a "guideline", if I remember correctly. My "guideline senses" tell me to food free this one. It's a no brainer. I WILL speak with the COOPERATIVE SPED DIRECTOR (over everyone) when I see her tomorrow (bus incident). mwa-ha..haha....

Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 09, 2012, 09:38:06 PM
A hard time reading??


Is she seriously thinking that you're going to SWALLOW this explanation??  :rofl:



Good for you, btw, pursuing food free.  Geeeeeeez, you'd really think that some people were being offered a root canal without anesthesia the way they treat the idea of modifying food plans, wouldn't you?   :insane:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: lakeswimr on February 09, 2012, 09:45:10 PM
Good luck! 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 09, 2012, 10:12:11 PM
A hard time reading??


Is she seriously thinking that you're going to SWALLOW this explanation??  :rofl:




oh it felt more like attempted entry from the other end.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: eragon on February 10, 2012, 07:08:32 AM
its very odd from a uk point of view to hear so much school involvement in valentines day. NOTHING happens in uk schools. Certainly no parties or food. cards may be exchanged, but not everyone takes part .

why is this considered a a suitable activity in a school day? what educational value does this have? (love for each other is not just one day a year!) 

it sounds like such madness and i cant see any positive aspect to it!

i thought valentine was for adult lovers, not kids!
this is all apart from the allergy side of things, and heaps more stress on families with food allergies, for little reason i can see.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: ajasfolks2 on February 10, 2012, 09:19:33 AM
eragon --

Part of the problem in the US is the overcommercialization and our unchecked consumerism -- the candy manufacturers have gone "whole hog" on the children in this country -- and Halloween, Valentines, and Easter PLUS the obvious Christmas are BIG for them in terms of dollars.

Once upon a time in the US, Valentines was about cards and small, sweet thing (nice deed or small token, not necessarily candy) for one's sweetheart.

Our nation is over-the-top with everything anymore.

It will be the death of us.

Actually, it already is.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 10, 2012, 10:03:26 AM
Eragon, I think that you have hit the crux of the matter RIGHT here:

why is this considered a a suitable activity in a school day? what educational value does this have?

Well, American educators would mumble something about cultural literacy and traditions, etc.  But the truth is that much of what is wrong with this nation's K through 12 educational system is over-the-top non-educational uses of the school day.

Truly, "instructional" activities and time in school are not as plentiful as they used to be.  They've gotten squeezed out by the bloated, gobbling PIG of 'fun-fun-fun' that revolves around, you guessed it--

food-food-food and with that, as Ajas noted, $$, $$, $$.

It's rampant conspicuous consumption, in reality.   :disappointed:

Of course, the upshot is that kids are now expected to make up the instructional difference on their own (and their parents') time-- as in, homework loads of 2+ hours even for elementary students... and what CLASSROOM instructional time remains is reserved for teaching them how to successfully read and take standardized tests. 

 :dunce:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: eragon on February 10, 2012, 10:13:16 AM
I did think that, but really , that doesnt sound good.   If the uk schools had this as a topic included in planning, EVERY area would be linked, and proven to fullfill  the national curriculum!

Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 10, 2012, 10:24:01 AM
OH, but it is.

LOL.

Of course, some of those explanations of goals and outcomes and assessment methods stretch the bounds of credibility so far that I have trouble believing that anyone could possibly say them aloud with a straight face...



but they are fulfilling some curriculum objective somewhere, I assure you.   :disappointed:  Because, see, there isn't any way to stop educators from basically lying through their teeth about it-- and they DO.  Regularly.


"Eating M&M's art in class will give children greater familiarity with color identification and the use of novel media in art.  The lesson objectives include:  1) improved color awareness, b) improving sensory awareness in the areas of tasting and seeing, and c) mastery of the imaginative process needed to create individual artwork intended only for the artist.  These objectives will be measured by informal teacher assessment during the lesson, and by self-reflective activies for the children (they will be creating edible art)."

(and no, I just made that one up, but HONESTLY, I have seen this done so many times that I could do one of these in my sleep and so could most other educators.)
It's delusional. 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: YouKnowWho on February 10, 2012, 11:29:58 AM
OH, but it is.

LOL.

Of course, some of those explanations of goals and outcomes and assessment methods stretch the bounds of credibility so far that I have trouble believing that anyone could possibly say them aloud with a straight face...



but they are fulfilling some curriculum objective somewhere, I assure you.   :disappointed:  Because, see, there isn't any way to stop educators from basically lying through their teeth about it-- and they DO.  Regularly.


"Eating M&M's art in class will give children greater familiarity with color identification and the use of novel media in art.  The lesson objectives include:  1) improved color awareness, b) improving sensory awareness in the areas of tasting and seeing, and c) mastery of the imaginative process needed to create individual artwork intended only for the artist.  These objectives will be measured by informal teacher assessment during the lesson, and by self-reflective activies for the children (they will be creating edible art)."

(and no, I just made that one up, but HONESTLY, I have seen this done so many times that I could do one of these in my sleep and so could most other educators.)
It's delusional.

You may have made it up, this is the exact mantra that my school keeps trying to shove down my throat every time I dare mention removing food from the classroom.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: YouKnowWho on February 10, 2012, 11:34:30 AM
The bigger question here is why are lay-people discussing another child's personal medical information.  This is not a dig against Arkadia. 

Why are room mom's in charge of food?  Why are they okay with leaving kids out? 

Why does there have to be food at every single event? 

I have been to numerous food holiday parties.  It's not the food that excites the kids - it's the crafts and the games.  Maybe I am just dense.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: lakeswimr on February 10, 2012, 12:03:24 PM
I agree Youknowhow, and wish someone would write all that into an article that would be able to help convince others see it this way, too.  I also do not get why it is seen as OK to leave FA kids out by people I know would NEVER be OK with it if roles were reversed.  I don't understand the thought process.  I told someone I thought it was that they valued the food more than our children's lives and that person told me it isn't that--it is that they value their idea of what they want for their child over what I want for my child.  I don't know.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: DrummersMom on February 10, 2012, 12:08:37 PM
I'm room mom this year and for us, it's the teacher who is food crazy. Teacher requests no peanut products but doesn't seem to think other allergens (milk, eggs, tree nuts) are as dangerous. DS will not be attending Valentine's Day party because food activity is not safe for him. Not a battle I can fight right now and other school staff do not think it's a big deal that allergens are to be served. They want a note from doc stating it is unsafe for him to be in room during this type of activity/food function.

I asked DS if he would write something about why food activities with food allergens are dangerous and how it makes him feel. He's going to do a Power Point and he's only 10. Of course he'll get some helpful info from links provided by mom.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: CMdeux on February 10, 2012, 04:06:48 PM
I agree Youknowhow, and wish someone would write all that into an article that would be able to help convince others see it this way, too.  I also do not get why it is seen as OK to leave FA kids out by people I know would NEVER be OK with it if roles were reversed.  I don't understand the thought process.  I told someone I thought it was that they valued the food more than our children's lives and that person told me it isn't that--it is that they value their idea of what they want for their child over what I want for my child.   I don't know.

Uhhh... okay, I understand that isn't an entirely "rational" statement intended to be picked apart logically...
(and I've heard similar things over the years, too, fwiw... so I suspet this is quite a common rationale)

BUT--

What THEY want for their child = FUN!  Birthday indulgence!  Feeling special-special-special in front of all his/her classmates... warm happy glow of... happiness, let's say (being generous, since I strongly suspect that in at least some cases, it might well be "smug" or "superior" instead, but how ugly is THAT?)


versus what FA moms want, which would be...

I "want" for my child = for my child to not be made:

a) dead,
b) permanently brain-damaged
c) terrified for his/her life while his/her peers and trusted authority figure(s) laugh and have fun by isolating him/her
d) made the butt of jokes or insensitive commentary by everyone in his/her surroundings


I mean, that is the comparison that we are talking about here.  It really is.   They simply don't even understand that a and b on my list are real, or that those might be "needs" rather than WANTS.

That's why I still view that statement as patently callous and selfish.  Sorry, but one person's desire to IMPROVE already good feelings/self-esteem at the price of another child's terror (or actual harm) = 'inhumane and more than a wee bit sociopathic.'

That is truly akin to the kind of thinking that serial killers use about their victims; a disengagement from them as "human" with the same fears, needs, and relevance as the killer's.  I think that other parents (cupcake queens, mind) DEHUMANIZE us and our children so that they don't have to feel guilty about what they choose to do anyway.

   :misspeak:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 17, 2012, 07:58:18 AM
I posted elsewhere how the party turned out (pretty uneventful), and will try to find the post and transcribe it here. I will say I noted moms reading labels to determine if the Hershey Syrup was okay for a milk allergy. Not sure if that was okay with his parents, no one told me one way or another. Anyways....before I knew it they were squirting Hershey Syrup in his bowl for him to dip his lemon bar in. (He apparently asked for it). The moms started making some comments, faces, and before you knew it the kids at his table (not my daughter) were taunting him with things like "ewwwwwwwwwwww, that's gross", that trickled over to other tables.  I put on my stern face and told them NOT it's never nice to make fun of ANYTHING about another student.  I got some "oh, were not making fun" and I told them "oh, you are". I told them then, it wasn't being a Bucket Filler. It wasn't "Kind", or "Responsible", or "Respectful". That put an instant stop to it. But really, if it weren't for comments of adults, I don't think it would have started.

Parents pretty much run these room parties, and there is a need to know as far as personal information or plans are.....but if there weren't parties, there wouldn't be a need...
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: lakeswimr on February 17, 2012, 08:20:33 AM
CM--I agree.  Another person's *feelings* are not more important than a FA child's *life*.  The fact that the feelings are often put higher than safety and inclusion of the FA child is mind boggling.

I agree Youknowhow, and wish someone would write all that into an article that would be able to help convince others see it this way, too.  I also do not get why it is seen as OK to leave FA kids out by people I know would NEVER be OK with it if roles were reversed.  I don't understand the thought process.  I told someone I thought it was that they valued the food more than our children's lives and that person told me it isn't that--it is that they value their idea of what they want for their child over what I want for my child.   I don't know.

Uhhh... okay, I understand that isn't an entirely "rational" statement intended to be picked apart logically...
(and I've heard similar things over the years, too, fwiw... so I suspet this is quite a common rationale)

BUT--

What THEY want for their child = FUN!  Birthday indulgence!  Feeling special-special-special in front of all his/her classmates... warm happy glow of... happiness, let's say (being generous, since I strongly suspect that in at least some cases, it might well be "smug" or "superior" instead, but how ugly is THAT?)


versus what FA moms want, which would be...

I "want" for my child = for my child to not be made:

a) dead,
b) permanently brain-damaged
c) terrified for his/her life while his/her peers and trusted authority figure(s) laugh and have fun by isolating him/her
d) made the butt of jokes or insensitive commentary by everyone in his/her surroundings


I mean, that is the comparison that we are talking about here.  It really is.   They simply don't even understand that a and b on my list are real, or that those might be "needs" rather than WANTS.

That's why I still view that statement as patently callous and selfish.  Sorry, but one person's desire to IMPROVE already good feelings/self-esteem at the price of another child's terror (or actual harm) = 'inhumane and more than a wee bit sociopathic.'

That is truly akin to the kind of thinking that serial killers use about their victims; a disengagement from them as "human" with the same fears, needs, and relevance as the killer's.  I think that other parents (cupcake queens, mind) DEHUMANIZE us and our children so that they don't have to feel guilty about what they choose to do anyway.

   :misspeak:
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: lakeswimr on February 17, 2012, 08:22:10 AM
Good job stopping that, Ark.  I don't ever put up with that type of thing from kids, either.  Too many teachers don't step in and think kids should learn to deal with it.  But it isn't socially acceptable behavior and it is the adult's job to teach children that. 

Does that other parent realize that room mothers determined whether or not a food was safe for her child?  I'd tell her so at least she knows this is happening.  Sounds like a future accident waiting to happen.  Hopefully not, though!
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: becca on February 17, 2012, 08:22:40 AM
I agree Youknowhow, and wish someone would write all that into an article that would be able to help convince others see it this way, too.  I also do not get why it is seen as OK to leave FA kids out by people I know would NEVER be OK with it if roles were reversed.  I don't understand the thought process.  I told someone I thought it was that they valued the food more than our children's lives and that person told me it isn't that--it is that they value their idea of what they want for their child over what I want for my child.  I don't know.

THIS!  It gets me so riled.  Like we want the food allergies to affect our children.  Just like they want cupcakes for theirs.  Do those sort of people really think this is about different wants? 

I had/well still have, a mom at our school like this.  I cramped her style when she would send an email out, "I will be making cupcakes for the GS meeting(she was assistant leader).  They will not be safe for the girls with food allergies."  WTF???  How can she not see how offensive that is, never mind exclusionary?  So, our big falling out began with my reply all:  "That sounds fun!  I will make safe cupcakes for the girls with allergies so they can also enjoy a cupcake with their friends."  I guess SHE was furious?  She had told a couple of mutual friends that the allergies were "just too much"  and "getting ot her."  Looking for sympathy.  Both moms she said this to have either a food allergic child or celiac in the family!  She "felt compromised" by the allergies.  WTF? 

I just cannot get over this attitude.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: suevv on February 17, 2012, 12:40:30 PM
CMDeux said, among other things, she wanted her child not to be:

c) terrified for his/her life while his/her peers and trusted authority figure(s) laugh and have fun by isolating him/her
d) made the butt of jokes or insensitive commentary by everyone in his/her surroundings

Even setting aside the immediate health risks of food allergies - which for some unfathomable reason aren't enough to stop school-food problems - we only recently realized how profoundly and horribly these two factors were impacting our 4 year old in his preschool.  Having removed him from the school, I now realize his development had been on "pause" for the last three months he was there.  He was spending the entire day in defense mode - and that was carrying over to home.  The poor little guy was exhausted and demoralized to a degree I failed to see until he recovered over the Christmas break.  I do wish there could be some real science done on the adverse impact from school-food problems on our FA kids.  Maybe that could somehow tip the scales.  I don't know.  It's just all so frustrating.

 
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: ajasfolks2 on February 19, 2012, 03:15:58 PM
suevv --  :grouphug:

The adverse impact can be staggering for some (maybe most) kids -- and often not detected as early as you seem to have grasped.

Wish I had scribbled down a quote I heard on brand new MSNBC show (Melissa Harris-Perry) this morning.  Going to try to find it -- she was speaking as to rights for a different population (not the disabled) but her words were such that I wanted to have them for our LTFA kids -- had to do with right to inclusion in the community and with privileges and emotional aspect.

I'll try hard to find & get them here.

Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Arkadia on February 19, 2012, 03:59:04 PM

Does that other parent realize that room mothers determined whether or not a food was safe for her child?  I'd tell her so at least she knows this is happening.
no idea how to contact her.
 at a birthday party i met saw the pa mom.  close quarters, she was dropping off a substitute cupcake, and I introduced myself as another mother of someone with a peanut allergy. ie:  "oh, my son has a peanut allergy, I'm staying, let me know....blah blah blah..." and I got the cold shoulder. Ice freezing cold. Most pa, parents, in my experience, want to fit in. They don't want to be "THAT mom.". That's the feeling I got, and if a parent's wishes aren't point blank communicated in a classroom, that's the way I interpret it:  "Don't bug me, I want my child and I to "fit" in."

They don't want to talk to us, period. We are the minority.
Title: Re: FAAN recommendations for Valentines Day School Parties <roll eyes>
Post by: Carefulmom on February 19, 2012, 06:36:43 PM
I posted elsewhere how the party turned out (pretty uneventful), and will try to find the post and transcribe it here. I will say I noted moms reading labels to determine if the Hershey Syrup was okay for a milk allergy. Not sure if that was okay with his parents, no one told me one way or another. Anyways....before I knew it they were squirting Hershey Syrup in his bowl for him to dip his lemon bar in. (He apparently asked for it). The moms started making some comments, faces, and before you knew it the kids at his table (not my daughter) were taunting him with things like "ewwwwwwwwwwww, that's gross", that trickled over to other tables.  I put on my stern face and told them NOT it's never nice to make fun of ANYTHING about another student.  I got some "oh, were not making fun" and I told them "oh, you are". I told them then, it wasn't being a Bucket Filler. It wasn't "Kind", or "Responsible", or "Respectful". That put an instant stop to it. But really, if it weren't for comments of adults, I don't think it would have started.

Parents pretty much run these room parties, and there is a need to know as far as personal information or plans are.....but if there weren't parties, there wouldn't be a need...

As a parent of a milk allergic child, Hershey`s syrup would probably be okay, but it would have to be a fresh bottle.  I doubt the moms thought of that.  If the Hershey`s syrup has been used to squirt into ice cream and the bottle touched the ice cream, then there can be small amounts of ice cream in the syrup that was squirted into the bowl of the milk allergic kid.  For some milk allergic kids, that would be epi and ER.  How can the school not see that they are creating a liability situation by letting moms decide what is safe for a milk allergic child who is not their child?  People are so food obsessed that they are unable to think rationally.  They don`t want the liability of having a non medical person using an epipen, but they don`t mind having parties where food is served that allergic kids are eating without having the mom of the allergic child okaying it.  That is just stupid.